Pop-funk verse, acoustic guitar in chorus, tempo changes throughout with Brian Eno on synthesisers.
the Court:
Similar to ‘Panopticom with piano at outro and Brian Eno on synthesisers.
Playing for Time:
Emotional piano ballad accompanied by strings.
i/o:
Lyrically focused, it grows from a relaxing melody into a singalong anthem.
Four Kinds of Horses:
Briano Eno on synthesisers and electric worms, half-spoken verse, rousing bridge, and a subliminal message chorus.
Road to Joy:
Brian Eno on production, uplifting track with a catchy hook.
So Much:
An emotional track over the piano with Soweto Gospel Choir.
Olive Tree:
Classic Peter Gabriel with an air-punching chorus.
Love Can Heal:
Something of a lullaby.
This is Home:
Outstanding vocals over a fantastic production.
And Still:
An emotional track addressing the death of his mother.
Live and Let Live:
Brian Eno on synthesisers and rhythm programming, Soweto Gospel Choir also features. Peter said the late Nelson Mandela and the late Desmond Tutu inspired the track. It’s a track about love and forgiveness.
Conclusion:
This is a quintessential Peter Gabriel album, which isn’t a bad thing, but the tracks are incredibly long, and I would describe the production like a river—everything flows, but the songs all sound similar, with some exceptions. I don’t know how this got to No.1 when the kids these days stream music, and I wouldn’t have Peter Gabriel at the top of their list. I can only think that “i/o” has been bought for parents/grandparents, uncles and aunties as a Christmas present. Still, fair play to him for managing to score a No.1 album in this day and age.
Song recommendations: ‘Panopticom’, ‘Four Kinds of Horses’, ‘Live and Let Live’
have no idea where I first heard Robbie Williams. Take That appeared out of nowhere in the 90s and became extremely popular without a steady rise. I don’t mind some of Robbie’s work since he decided to go solo in 1997, which started with the indie-inspired ‘Old Before I Die’. I love that song, but Robbie isn’t too keen on it when you read his 2016 autobiography “Reveal”. He appears to hate it with a passion. I used to love hearing it on the radio, on television or on the jukebox at the local Riley’s snooker club. It epitomised the whole indie revival movement during that period. I am surprised by his submission because after being discarded by the Gallagher brothers, he said in his book, it didn’t deter him from liking Oasis, and he enjoys a lot of indie music. I don’t fucking care if some of you are smirking at me reading his book, it was an intriguing read, and you get to know the honest Robbie and not the one slaughtered by the media. So, my initial plan was to listen to the new tracks on “XXV”, but he had other ideas. Yes, it is his greatest hits, but not in their original guise. The songs have been reimagined with Jules Buckley conducting an orchestra, and there is even a Beethoven version of ‘Angels’. That’s the introduction over; now to the review. I have elected to analyse each classic and new song track-by-track.
Let’s begin:
Let Me Entertain You:
No one can forget this beast of an anthem with its rock attitude. When this was recorded, the La’s and Lightning Seeds drummer Chris Sharrock was drumming for Robbie. Of course, Chris would go on to join Robbie’s friends Oasis, Beady Eye, and his least favourite Gallagher brother Noel Gallagher’s High Flying Birds. The song carries on in the same vein, but the horns and choir bring that celestial finish to it. Already I am impressed.
Come Undone:
A friend had this on a Now That’s What I Call Music compilation in 2003, and I was reading the footnotes. Tupac Shakur inspires this song. I was shocked to hear this because I don’t hear any references to Pac in the song. On a side note, Robbie and Pac met in 1995 at the Versace birthday party. They both shared a joint, and they got on almost immediately. Pac didn’t know about Robbie’s portrayal by the media and didn’t seem to care either. They shot the shit about life and, for a brief moment, became friends. Has the song improved much since the original? Only slightly. Not much to write about.
Love my Life:
In the book, Robbie said he wrote this for Theodora(his daughter.) to tell her never to forget to love your life despite what others might say about you. Again, the orchestra lift this song to another level; to be honest; it is fit for the West End when they do a musical on Robbie.
Millenium:
There was no point in tweaking this track. It doesn’t enhance it, as the original already has a stringed section. I believe it was pilfered from a James Bond theme song. He was better off not bothering to rework this one.
the Road to Mandalay:
Again, a pointless rework. The original is better.
Tripping:
For the third time in succession, the track didn’t need necessary work. I am sure this one catches your attention by starting off with a reggae vibe before returning to the familiarity. You feel cheated when the reggae falls away after the introduction. I’d have preferred a reggae vibe on the rework, in all honesty. I cannot recall a single track where Robbie has done reggae.
Bodies:
I’ve never been a fan of it, and the rework didn’t do much for me.
Candy:
Jesus. This song made me cringe when it came out, and still makes me cringe now. Robbie is better than bubblegum pop.
Supreme:
Again, I believe another song pilfered from a James Bond film. I didn’t feel a rework was necessary. I mean, what could Jules have possibly done to improve it? The original has an orchestra. There are, however, female backing vocals. Still didn’t do much to improve, though.
Strong:
Again, Robbie puts on his indie head in the original, and to be honest, there is not much difference between the XXV version and the original. It’s a photo finish which is better.
Eternity:
Just like ‘Strong’, there isn’t much difference in both versions.
No Regrets:
My favourite track off “I’ve Been Expecting You”, and it has to be the original that will remain my favourite. He tries to make this more upbeat when the original is melancholic, which fits with the concept.
She’s the One:
I love this cover of World Party’s track, even though the original is much better. It was a nice nod to World Party, but Karl Wallinger has said on many occasions he now hates performing the song and that Robbie ruined it for him. In the book, Robbie mentions how through a third party, Karl said, “When you see him, tell him he’s a cunt”. If Karl hated the original cover, he isn’t going to be too fond of the XXV version, either. However, I believe the majority will agree with him this time.
Feel:
I was not too fond of it then, didn’t like it when Peter Schmeichel played on it live, and I still don’t like it now.
Rock DJ:
When this came out in the summer of 2000, I liked it. Then, it was played to death, so I stopped listening to it, and as I got older, I could not stand it. Even listening to the rework was too much.
Kids:
I loved this when it came out in the autumn of 2000, with its rock attitude and the collaboration with Kylie Minogue. Kylie features in the rework. Again, a photo finish of which one is best.
Angels:
The original pisses all over this. Do look out for a surprise later on, though.
Lost:
Now, we have come to a brand new track. It was made for this album. Yes, I know it was actually made for this record, but what I mean is it’s a perfect fit. The orchestra musicians compliment each other.
Nobody Someday:
An acoustic guitar accompanies Robbie’s vocals, accompanied by a soft choir. A vast improvement on the original.
Lazy Days:
The original itself was lazy instrumentally and vocally. The rework brings it to life—the orchestra playing a pivotal role.
Hot Fudge:
I never liked it and still don’t.
Sexed up:
Again, I wouldn’t say I liked the original, and my concentration wavered on this one.
More than This:
Another brand new song. Once again, it is a perfect fit, just like ‘Lost’.
Disco Symphony:
Another new track that does exactly what it says. I can see this one being played at parties and wedding receptions imminently. Very uptempo and very disco.
Better Man:
You’re better off listening to the original.
Home Thoughts from Abroad:
The Magic FM moment on the album. Although to be fair, the majority of the record will fit nicely on their playlists.
the World and Her Mother:
The final new track has the Robbie signature written all over it.
Into the Silence:
Again, another photo finish.
Angels (Beethoven AI):
This song is merged with Beethoven’s ‘Unfinished 10th Symphony’, and fuck me; it fits in perfectly. I never thought I would see the day when ‘Angels’ collaborates with ‘Unfinished 10th Symphony’. I was blown away when I heard it, and it fucking destroys the original. That was a very clever move by Robbie. This version is beyond space; it’s that good.
Song recommendations: ‘Angels(Beethoven AI)’, ‘Nobody Someday’, ‘Disco Symphony’
7/10
Why such an average rating, you ask? Well, because I prefer the originals.
As you can imagine, Hannah Reid is once again a critical group member, and I especially liked her vocal performance on ‘Intro’. Many told me before I got the chance to listen and review this album that it had a hint of Clannad about it. Considering Hannah’s Celtic roots, this didn’t surprise me, but I’m afraid I have to disagree with most of their assumptions about this record sounding like Clannad. Yes, ‘Intro’ does sound like a Clannad track used for a soundtrack or otherwise, but I didn’t see much else resembling Clannad’s inspiration. Another three to four songs, but that’s about it.
It differs from the last album from 2017 because it flirts with experimentation more, adding more orchestral, Celtic, and cinematic sounds. There is a touch of ambience in the album, too. Now, remember I spoke about ‘Intro’ sounding like Clannad earlier? Here’s why. Although Hannah doesn’t sing, she still uses angelic vocalising with her voice while chiming bells, strings, vinyl crackles, and a haunting Celtic ambience dances with her vocalising. Its cinematic feel is glorious to listen to in surround sound and sends chills down your spine with its haunting. It would be ideal for a film based on Celtic folklore. Clannad may have heard this track and might be interested in working with Hannah.
Hannah’s vocals do not deviate much during the entire album. The record then goes from ‘Intro’ to the ‘Californian Soil’ title track. Many have drawn comparisons with Massive Attack on this.
Still, as always going against the grain, I found some other artists I felt drew more comparison in Alanis Morrisette. Why? Because to me, the riff sounded more like her 90s hit ‘You Oughta Know’ not because of the aggressive vocals or subject matter, but just that.
After that, a record is packed with Hannah’s trademark vocals, sometimes angelic vocals, synths that are sorelaxing you fall into a trance, strings, Clannad-inspired melodies, and sometimes the guitar riff makes an appearance.
Because of the calming and light instrumentation, you could also draw comparisons to My Morning Jacket. Like the American band, London Grammar has allowed you to sit back, stare at the ceiling, or close your eyes and dream of entering another realm.
Of course, aside from their generic sound, ‘All My Love’ is a cinematic ballad, and ‘Closer America’ is more melancholic than what they usually do. The latter is about chasing the American dream and crushing it with brutal honesty.
However, I will close on the trackside of the review with ‘Missing’. When I heard this, I instantly thought of Zero 7’s ‘Destiny’ with its downtempo, which felt precisely like the 2001 track. Still, Hannah’s vocals mirrored Sophie Barker’s and Sia Furler’s (Yes, THAT Sia Furler. She came over to England in 1998 from Australia. In fact, it is worth listening to some of her earlier work like ‘Little Men’ and ‘Drink to Get Drunk’). Not only have you got a sense of Sophie and Sia in it, but I am going to say the great Sadé, too.
The lyrical content is centred mainly around Hannah’s fight with feminism and the sexism and misogyny she has encountered many times since joining the industry. It gives more energy and passion to the record because it lets her emotionsshine through with conviction.
The record is quite melancholic for the group, more mature than the previous records, with some tracks fit for a film soundtrack, inspired by Hannah’s Celtic roots and subject matters that need urgent addressing, like the sexism towards women that isstill experienced by many within the industry to the present day. As for the Clannad connection? It was less heavily influenced than some people have made out. Like I said, three to four tracks at the maximum.
Song recommendations: ‘Intro’, ‘Californian Soil’, ‘Missing’
Whatever you may think about the chief songwriter and band member in Take That, he knows how to write a fucking song. As far as I am aware, he’s also bizarrely a Liverpool fan from Manchester, which is quite a rarity. Although his solo career didn’t go too well after the break up of Take That (They reformed in 2005 and are still going strong to date.), he was still very successful behind the scenes, writing songs for various artists and some of the songs he wrote for them might surprise you because you thought he was the forgotten man. So, is this Gary’s second solo album? It’s called “Music Played by Humans”, released almost two decades after his debut.
“Who’s Driving This Thing?” opens the record, and Gary can be heard introducing the album to the band in the studio and sharing laughs and jokes with them. It sets the mood for the whole record, which is very big band and swing. I’m not sure if he writes for Michael Buble (Who, funnily enough, does feature.), but the delivery is very much the same as how Michael would do it.
“The Big Bass Drum” is one of the essential tracks on the album, and Gary selflessly lets the musicians and the band take the limelight and blends in by accompanying them. For once, he hasn’t taken centre stage.
Again, Gary shows his abilities as a songwriter by switching moods and subjects. In “This Is My Time”, he talks about dying from love. “Enough is Enough” featuring Beverley Knight might prove his ability to write songs on any subject, but this track is not as melancholic as the title suggests. Now, the next track I thought I would want to skip and hate with a passion is “the Kind of Friend I Need”. Why? Because James Corden is on it, but he can sing, and it works. You can hear them ribbing each other between their verses, and as the album closes, James proclaims that he’s the best singer on the track. Gary replies, “It’s my album, you know?” I found the whole track lighthearted and funny. If you like big band and swing, this album is for you. I also was surprised to find out this from Gary. This kind of record should be played at restaurants or lounge bars. Very easy on the ear, funny, and guaranteed to make you feel upbeat.
NB: I later discovered that this is (Incredibly.) It’s Gary’s fifth solo studio album.
Song recommendations: “the Kind of Friend I Need”, “the Big Bass Drum”, “This is My Time”
Honest Opinions 