Week 51: Pink Floyd- Wish You Were Here 50

This Dolby Atmos 50th anniversary edition of “Wish You Were Here” may appear to be a cash grab, but underneath the surface, that isn’t the case. The bonus material, which I will discuss later, has been carefully selected. The album’s emotional weight has been enhanced by the clarity and space, so all the emotions expressed with newly resonant without losing the original spirit.

My highlights from the new version include ’Shine on You Crazy Diamond (Parts 1-4)’, which benefits from the expanded soundstage, with its synths and guitar lines gradually blossoming, making it more immersive. I also like the new version of the title track, which brings the acoustic textures closer to the track’s emotion. ‘Welcome to the Machine’ is precise and more imposing, with the mechanical elements more defined, and the final track I will mention is ‘Have a Cigar’ because the use of the improved separation gives it more bite.

I feel the bonus material only enhances the latest edition of the album. We have a new mix of the record, remastered and using Dolby Atmos, and unreleased tracks from a live concert at the LA Arena in 1975, that offers a raw edge of the band improvising onstage. There are also alternate and early versions that show how the sound has progressed throughout the years. This helps take away the idea that this edition is just a “cash grab” or “filler,” because every version has substance.

“Wish You Were Here 50” celebrates the anniversary respectfully. The new versions brighten the tracks, and the bonus material adds texture and context. It is a must-have for Pink Floyd connoisseurs, and Dolby Atmos will introduce a younger generation of listeners to the band. My one gripe with it, and to be honest, it is to be expected of them, is that the songs are very long. There are Dolby Atmos versions and live tracks that run over 25 minutes. Pink Floyd connoisseurs will adore it because it shows off the band’s prowess, whereas a casual or new listener may find it a bit too much. There are also long intros, where the first lyrics are sometimes delivered at the 8-minute mark. As for the record, the songs remain the same, but with the element of Dolby Atmos, they have never been more clearer. You hear everything, and it’s glorious.

Song recommendations: ‘Have a Cigar’, ’Shine on You Crazy Diamond (Parts 1-4)’, ‘Wish You Were Here’


8/10