the Edge

Week 12: U2- Songs of Surrender

~ honestopinions19 ~ Leave a comment

I must confess that I was fucking terrified of how to approach this review. I wondered if it would be a written paragraph review, track-by-track, or short track-by-track. I mean, U2 are the most fucking iconic band ever, and I wanted to do them justice with a review of this. 

The band started in Dublin during the mid-70s when Larry Mullen Jr requested band members wanted on the school notice board. He would get five responses, which included Bono, the Edge, Edge’s brother, and Adam Clayton. Before the lads settled on U2, Larry thought he would be in charge of the band until it appeared 10 minutes into the formation that Paul Hewson, aka Bono, had other ideas. Dik Evans (Edge’s brother, who has gone on to have a successful music career) would be phased out a year after the formation of Feedback, then the Hype. Ivan McCormick lasted a mere two weeks before being dropped. He would go on to become a composer.

Since then, the rest of history. The band has several iconic albums packed with political issues, bombastic choruses, and stadium anthems. The band was very punky, to begin with, before working with Brain Eno, which proved highly challenging for the band, who fell out on several occasions with Brian during recording sessions. In a documentary, the band admitted that they hated those sessions because he wanted to bring his production watermark to the album. Bono would constantly push back. However, “the Joshua Tree”, which the band confessed, until they did the anniversary in 2017 and 2019, supported by the likes of Noel Gallagher’s High Flying Birds, they were not particularly fond of, but now have found some love for it. Many people are fond of “the Joshua Tree”, where the hits and stadium anthems started to roll in. There is no doubt that Brian’s second time working with the band changed their sound forever and made them more versatile from that moment on.

The band have been together for over four decades, and despite the squabbling during the recording sessions for “the Joshua Tree”, they haven’t got close to breaking up since. How did it get to this? Well, last year, Bono released a book called ‘Surrender’, an autobiography ranging from anecdotes about his time in U2 to meeting the Pope with bonus content in the audiobook. Bono would do acoustic versions of their iconic hits when he did a reading tour., which brought the “Songs of Surrender” to life.

From there, the band had this concept of doing stripped-back versions of all their hits (That’s a staggering 40.)over four discs titled after each member. The Album is over three hours of listening time in total. Anyway, I have opted for a brief track-by-track review, so here goes:

Disc 1: the Edge

One: 

Piano ballad, a gentle cymbal at the end of the chorus, soft vocals throughout, and the last chorus builds up with ghostly backing vocals and marching drums on the outro.

Where the Streets Have No Name: 

Cello intro, haunting synth verse, the piano joins on the chorus, synth rings out on outro.

Stories for Boys: 

Piano intro leading into verse, backing vocals on the verse, piano break, vocals over piano riff on the chorus, short piano riff outro.

11 O Clock Tick-Tock: 

Drums and acoustic intro, acoustic plucking and piano in verse 1, bass riff and Bono falsetto in chorus, harmonic vocal break, backing harmonies with piano in verse 2, acoustic solo joined by plucked acoustic, gentle electric guitar on outro

Out of Control: 

Acoustic solo intro, pulsating acoustic on the verse, reverb vocals over rhythmic acoustic on chorus 1, backing vocals on chorus 2, rhythmic acoustic on the bridge, acoustic solo break, bass on chorus 3, acoustic rings out on outro.

Beautiful Day: 

Piano ballad with pulsating acoustic with scratching and backing vocals, pulsating piano in chorus, harmonic vocals leading into verse 3, choral bridge, pulsating drums in chorus 2, and choral outro.

Bad: 

Acoustic intro over tambourine leading into verse, piano and strings join on verse 2, marching drums with an acoustic riff on the chorus, marching drums build before the harmonic outro.

Every Breaking Wave: 

Haunting piano riff intro is repeated in verses, with backing vocals on the bridge, light strings in chorus 1, reverb vocals in verse 2, synth joins in chorus 2, piano break, and piano riff outro with sustained high vocals.

Walk on (Ukraine): 

Plucked acoustic intro, backing vocals and bass join verse 2 with plucked acoustic, rhythmic acoustic on chorus 1, piano on chorus 2 with a light cymbal crash, pulsating piano on outro with riff.

Pride (in the Name of Love): 

Rhythmic acoustic with bass intro, backing vocals on the chorus, piano with an acoustic riff on break, electric guitar solo break with full band outro before fade out.

Disc 2: Larry

Who’s Gonna Ride Your Wild Horses: 

Pulsating acoustic, cello and piano in verses, a rhythmic acoustic riff in the chorus,  bass joins from verse 2, backing vocals from Edge in chorus 2, and synth rings out on the outro.

Get Out of Your Own Way: 

Drums, acoustic and backing vocals on the intro, bass joins in the verse, harmonic backing vocals with an acoustic riff on the chorus, and instrumental outro.

Stuck in a Moment You Can’t Get Out of: 

Acoustic intro leads into verse, backing vocals from Edge, bass joins on the chorus, bongos on verse 2, piano joins on the outro, and acoustic rings out.

Red Hill Mining Town:

Haunting synth and acoustic on intro leading into verse with drums, bass and Trombone Shorty, chorus 2 with harmonic backing vocals, sustained trombone on the outro.

Ordinary Love:

Acoustic riff intro leading into verse, synth, bass and backing vocals on the chorus, acoustic riff break between verses, acoustic rings out on outro.

Sometimes You Can’t Make it on Your Own:

Piano intro leading intro verse, falsetto backing vocals on bridge, electric guitar riff, marching drums, tubular bells on verse 4 and final chorus, piano and bass drum outro.

Invisible:

Acoustic riff, piano, bass and drums intro leading into verse, the song builds on the chorus with backing vocals leading into the instrumental break, full band outro before Bono and backing vocals acapella.

Dirty Day:

Cello intro leads into verse, Bono whispered vocals in verse, the electric guitar riff in chorus, the violin joins in verse 2, Bono’s vocals slightly louder in verse 3, backing vocals in chorus 3, sustained violin, Bono’s sustained vocals, and acoustic rings out on outro.

the Miracle (of Joey Ramone):

Acoustic lead and full band intro leading into verse, backing vocals on chorus, piano, acoustic and Bono harmonies on break, backing harmonies on verse 2, short acoustic break, harmonic vocals with an acoustic outro.

City of Blinding Lights:

Piano and bass intro, piano and Bono on verse 1, backing vocals on bridge, backing vocals and acoustic on chorus 1, electric guitar joins on chorus 2, haunting harmonic vocals break, piano rings out on outro.

Disc 3: Adam

Vertigo:

Violin and rhythmic acoustic intro, rhythmic acoustic verse, violin and acoustic on chorus and post-chorus, violin and acoustic break, cello outro.

I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For: 

Acoustic riff and tambourine intro lead into verse, Bono with mid-volume vocals, Edge backing vocals, and bass join on verse 2, electric guitar on break, piano and full drums join on verse 3, ghostly outro.

Electrical Storm:

Piano and electric guitar intro, piano in verse 1, rhythmic acoustic joins in verse 3, reverb vocals on the chorus, verse 4 same as verse 1, full band in verse 6, tambourine joins on the final chorus, light cymbal crash to end.

the Fly:

Bongos, full drums, bass and electric guitar on intro leading into verse, haunting backing vocals on the chorus, piano post-chorus, backbeat break before the verse, piano break, reverb falsetto vocals followed by an acoustic solo, then reverb vocal outro.

if God Will Send His Angels:

Piano intro, whispered vocals over the piano in verse, chorus with backing falsetto vocals before piano rings out, piano solo post-chorus, falsetto vocals to end verse 2, distant reverb vocals post-chorus 2, piano outro.

Desire:

Electric guitar intro, falsetto vocals, handclaps and keyboard reverb effect on the verse, fiddle solo on bridge, yoddling with backing vocals on bridge 2, keyboard reverb effect outro.

Until the End of the World:

Rhythmic acoustic intro, piano and acoustic on the verse, backing vocals on the chorus, acoustic break, acoustic solo after chorus 2, falsetto vocals on verse 3, light harmonic vocals with backing harmonic vocals outro.

Song for Someone:

Pulsating acoustic with piano intro leading into verse, backing vocals join on the bridge, piano solo with vocals on the chorus, piano solo with acoustic and bass, acoustic rings out on outro.

All I Want is You:

Panpipe effect with bass and drum intro leading into verse, acoustic lead on the chorus, rhythmic acoustic break with the full band, bongos and falsetto vocals on final chorus, bass and bongos outro.

Peace on Earth:

Acoustic intro, empty church ambience vocals, the choir joins acoustic on chorus, full band joins choir and acoustic on chorus 2.

Disc 4: Bono

With or Without You:

Acoustic bass and synth intro leading into verse, building post-chorus, vocals build on the bridge, full band on the final chorus, electric guitar solo with brief Bono harmonic vocal outro.

Stay(Faraway, So Close!):

Backing vocals over piano intro leading into verse, electric guitar and full band on verse 2, falsetto with falsetto backing vocals on chorus, piano and Bono vocals on verse 3, verse 4 as verse 2, brief instrumental break before the chorus, harmonic vocals with backing harmonic vocals break partially spoken word on outro with electric guitar ringing out.

Sunday Bloody Sunday:

Acoustic riff with harmonic vocals, rhythmic acoustic on the verse, Edge backing vocals on chorus with change in rhythm, acoustic break, bass joins on chorus 2, acoustic solo, three-string pluck outro.

Light of Home:

Acoustic riff with synth intro, backing vocals in verse, full band in the chorus, ghostly vocals in post-chorus, full band in verse 2, backing vocals on bridge, acoustic solo, sustained vocals before a change in tempo with backing vocals outro.

Cedarwood Road:

Rhythmic acoustic intro leading into verse, change of acoustic tempo with backing vocals on the chorus, reverb vocal effect on verse 2, change of rhythm with the full band on verse 3, reverb effect outro.

I Will Follow:

Acoustic riff with strings intro, piano and bass join on the verse, acoustic riff break, full band on verse 2, backing vocals on the chorus, brief acoustic solo, sudden stop to end.

Two Hearts Beat as One:

Piano, bass, beatboxing, funky intro. Pulsating drums with the full band on the verse, backing vocals on the bridge, funky break with electric guitar, and piano break before the outro.

Miracle Drug:

Drum intro leading into verse, the piano joins on the verse, backing vocals on the chorus, acoustic rings out, acoustic with Bono on verse 2, full band on verse 3, brief acoustic break before the bridge, brief silence before the final chorus, rhythmic drum outro.

the Little Things that Give You Away:

Acoustic and bass intro, keyboards join on the verse, full band on verse 2, acoustic break before verse 3, backing vocals with reverb on chorus 2, acoustic, keyboards and bass on verse 4, the song builds on the bridge before the brief acoustic solo break, acoustic rings out on outro.

40:

Haunting piano with electric guitar intro leading into verse, bass joins on the verse, backing vocals on the chorus, piano break.

Even if you are not a fan of U2, you will be after hearing this. Upon listening, you will soon realise every track has a unique originality to its original version. It is a monumental effort to reimagine songs; looking at what I’ve written, you might consider it tedious, but far from it.

Song recommendations: ‘Two Hearts Beat as One’, ‘Beautiful Day’, ‘Vertigo’

9/10

Week 17: Fontaines D.C.- Skinty Fia

~ honestopinions19 ~ Leave a comment
As you might recall, I wrote a review of their second album, “A Hero’s Death”, by accident. As you know, I write a review for the number one album each week or whenever a new one is on the top spot. Well, this particular week back in 2020, the Irish band were on course for the top spot, but the previous number one held them off. However, I wrote a review on “A Hero’s Death” because it was more or less certain on the back of this information. I listened to the record, wrote my review a day later, and uploaded it the following day. It’s nice to know I will not need to do a bit of background to introduce you to the lads from Dublin. I will, though, do something I have yet to do so far.

As you know, I have done track-by-track reviews, summary track-by-track reviews, and plain old, elongated reviews. I will do essential track reviews on the tracks I enjoyed this time. The album consists of ten tracks. I will write a review, long or short, on the highlights of “Skinty Fia”:

In ár gCroíthe go deo: 

This track opens the album and translates as “In Our Hearts Forever”. It’s nice to see some Gaeilge used by a band, particularly from Ireland. It has been a while since I’ve seen Gaeilge used by Irish bands, unless it is Clannad or the like. This song is steeped in Irish history—the song protests against the English who invaded Ireland 800 or more years ago. The band’s instrumentalists provide backing vocals, repeating the track title repeatedly as Grian enters over a glum and sinister bassline. The song is based on the event of Maggie Keane, who wanted a Celtic cross with the track name inscribed on the headstone. However, the occupying British Army brought the Church of England over, which denied Maggie’s request. Their reason is that the message was written in the native language, which would lead to political connotations. Despite this, the Irish courts ruled in favour of Maggie’s family. The band felt the song epitomises how the natives still need to fight for their identity. From the outset, the band have decided to go political. If that makes some of you uncomfortable because they want to talk about the occupation of Ireland, then stop reading this review and give the album a miss. 


Big Shot:


As you may well know, the Dubliners have moved across the sea to London, and this song reflects that. Whereas Dublin still has opportunities to expand, the band’s move to London has opened up more avenues than were on offer back in their native Dublin. The band can pursue their dream of being the best by moving across the sea. For example, look at some of these lyrics: “I travelled to Space”, found the moon too small, and home is a pin, rusting through a map, I go there to pray, do my resting at mass”. What Grian is saying, from what I can decipher, is that they have travelled around Ireland, but it isn’t enough to achieve their dream. Despite being a big city, Dublin is nothing compared to the other cities they have played in worldwide. They only return to Dublin when there is a break during touring (Or the tour has ended.) and attend mass. The last line, I believe to be they only have time to reflect and relax away from music when they go to mass (I am also Catholic like the lads, and you feel far from relaxed at mass. It feels like you are in the dock listening to a judge telling you how guilty you are.)


Jackie Down the Line: 


Another political track. I will explain why briefly, but this song is the opposite of ‘Big Shot’. The band talks about why they are proud to be from Dublin (In the title sense, at least.). The song has an Indie 90s feel to it. “Jackie” is a variation of “Jackeen”. This is a derogatory term used by people outwith of Dublin. A Jackeen is someone who has become an “Irish Brit”. They have embraced the British culture and have become flag-wavers of the Union Jack. I first heard this track on the Late Late Show with Jimmy Fallon. It featured a steady drumbeat, acoustic guitar, and a reverb effect on Conor Curley’s electric guitar—a method used by his counterpart Edge from U2. The song talks about a woman named Sally, a toxic male killed. I haven’t looked into the case, but it highlights that there is still this problem of men attacking women in Ireland. Indeed, Grian’s vocals are melancholic. You can hear his soul slide away during the verses as he foretells the fable.


I Love You: 


So far, I haven’t heard anything like the punk-infused songs I had heard on their previous albums, and this track was no different. This time, the band took influences from Joy Division, New Order, and the Cure. It reminded me of a darker version of ‘Blue Monday’. Why? It wasn’t quite a dance track but had that Peter Hook bassline. I am sure I have seen Deego sporting a t-shirt of all the bands before now. So, it is no surprise he has added Peter Hook and Simon Gallup basslines. The subject revolves around the Irish youth, how they are shackled by capitalism and religion, how the lockdown has affected their well-being and the sinking feeling of what the future holds. At the same time, while trapped in this current situation. Grian’s delivery is spot-on for the subject. He delivers the vocals with ferocious anger as he addresses the issues and describes how he felt growing up in that situation.


Bloomsday: 


It leads off from ‘I Love You’ because it, too, is dark. This time, however, it goes even more profound and sinister. Again, over this gloomy instrumentation, Grian’s delivery is perfect. His lyrics sound like a man talking with a soft and melancholic tone. Again, Grian highlights the lack of hope for the youth in Ireland, particularly in his native Dublin.


Skinty Fia:


 As you can tell by the name, this is the title track. Does it move away from the previous two songs about Dublin? The answer is no. The song can be described as darkwave over a low bassline as Grian talks about Dublin’s shortcomings.


Roman Holiday: 


Unlike, let’s call it the Doomed Dublin trilogy, this song is more upbeat and has a message of hope. Once again, the guitar effect Edge uses is utilised by Curley over a stark bassline and fragmented percussion. The song is quite apt with the current war in Eastern Europe. It is about a couple moving to Dublin who can be welcomed and make it their home, which Ukrainian refugees have been doing in Dublin and all over Europe. Even though you are not from Ireland, you can still embrace it and have an Irish heart. I first heard this at Alexandra Palace on the current tour.


the Couple Across the Way: 


In one of the quieter moments on the record, Grian sings alone, accompanied by an accordion and piano. Grian tells the story of looking out of his window and narrating a typical day in the life of his neighbours adjacent. He has never spoken to them to find out their names or interests. He observes them argue, make up, and repeat the cycle daily. He opts to assume the role of one half of the couple as the song nears the end and the story becomes more straightforward.


Nabokov: 

The album closer has a Verve air about it. Like the Verve, the track is melancholic, but Fontaines DC adds a fast tempo, whereas the Verve would opt for a plodding one. For those of you who are learned readers, you would have probably detected the song title is by a novelist, and just like in one of Nabokov’s books, the character in the track depicts that of Lolita—a lady who no longer feels optimistic and is fed up with being downtrodden. The only way out of the situation to end the pain is to take her own life. That sentiment is expressed in the lyrics “I did you a favour, I bled myself dry, ” as Grian delivers it, seemingly depicting the character screaming angrily. Some might say it is a dark and sinister way to close out, but the band have never been one to abide by the laws. They have always gone against the grain and diced with danger, which has worked since they started playing. Unlike “Dogrel” and “A Hero’s Death”, “Skinty Fia” has been sobering to listen to, and the subjects on offer invoke all the emotions we feel. The record also goes deep into our imaginations.


Song recommendations: ‘Jackie Down the Line’, ‘the Couple Across the Way’, ‘Roman Holiday’


9/10

Week Fourteen: 5 Seconds of Summer- C A L M aka Calum Ashton Luke Michael

~ honestopinions19 ~ Leave a comment

5_Seconds_of_Summer_-_Calm

I looked forward to reviewing this as they did a few festivals last year, and the lads from Perth, Australia, were on point. However, they should have stayed as pop punk like they were with their self-titled debut album. Unfortunately, going into the pop arena hasn’t worked with them on this record, and it just sounds poorly produced. It’s pretty much like their previous album, “Youngblood”. This reminds me of that record, as there is little change in direction.

For me, 5 Seconds of Summer is falling into the same trap Maroon 5 did. Maroon 5, when they first got started, were releasing good songs like “This Love”, “She Will be Loved”, and “Sunday Morning”. Unfortunately, then they started making shite like “Moves Like Jagger” and “Phone Booth”. I don’t mind listening to early Maroon 5 material but since 2011? Forget it. I am saying that any song with the potential for 5 Seconds of Summer is being massacred and turned into dogshit. The band have said leading on from their previous record that their inspiration is drawn from the 80s, but I don’t know what section of that era because the songs are incredibly flat and underwhelming. It’s a shame when you consider the producers behind this project, Louis Bell and Andrew Watt, who have worked with Ozzy Osbourne, Halsey, the Chainsmokers, the late Avicii, Post Malone, Lana Del Rey, and several others to significant effect. Unfortunately, this falls into their most minor inspirational works category. I mean, not even U2’s Edge or Rage Against the Machine’s Tom Morello could add anything to this record because the producers, with all their effects, have pissed all over their contributions. I mean, let’s face it, Edge and Tom Morello are very unique in the way they play the axe and are fucking amazing too, but even they couldn’t rescue a lacklustre album. Maybe if the producers didn’t piss about on the songs they featured on, the album might be worthy of its No. 1 spot. It’ll probably get a lot of streams, but that could be people like me who are listening to make a review on it. The number of streams counts for nothing and needs to be a fair reflection of how well an album is doing. The sales of it could be a different story. I hope so; it’s awful.

What’s quite puzzling is that they are actually extremely good live and remind me of Muse. I am not a great lover of Muse’s studio material, but live they are in a different sphere, and those songs take on a life of their own. The same goes for 5 Seconds of Summer. Now, I was still deciding about giving them a chance live, but I was left really impressed with the performance and the interaction with the crowd. It also begs the question, are they with the correct label? Because they seem to want, the band to churn out generic pop shite rather than let them be as creative as they are live. 

I found “Thin White Lies” quite comical for its reference to cocaine, but the songs that really stood out for me were “Teeth”, which has a bass line that sounds like it was inspired by listening to Bloc Party or Maximo Park and “Lover of Mine”, which is the penultimate track for blending an acoustic guitar with dubstep. Those are the only genuine creative moments I heard in the thirty-nine minutes. I hope they consider their options for the next album and move to another label because this company stifles their creativity in the studio. Even though live performances are where it really matters, it helps to add some of what

you pick up on the road to your creativity in the studio. I can’t fault them live, but in the studio, there is much work to do, and they really need to work out what their identity will be on future albums. They need to leave this record label and find one that will let them bring their live qualities into the studio. 5/10