This Dolby Atmos 50th anniversary edition of “Wish You Were Here” may appear to be a cash grab, but underneath the surface, that isn’t the case. The bonus material, which I will discuss later, has been carefully selected. The album’s emotional weight has been enhanced by the clarity and space, so all the emotions expressed with newly resonant without losing the original spirit.
My highlights from the new version include ’Shine on You Crazy Diamond (Parts 1-4)’, which benefits from the expanded soundstage, with its synths and guitar lines gradually blossoming, making it more immersive. I also like the new version of the title track, which brings the acoustic textures closer to the track’s emotion. ‘Welcome to the Machine’ is precise and more imposing, with the mechanical elements more defined, and the final track I will mention is ‘Have a Cigar’ because the use of the improved separation gives it more bite.
I feel the bonus material only enhances the latest edition of the album. We have a new mix of the record, remastered and using Dolby Atmos, and unreleased tracks from a live concert at the LA Arena in 1975, that offers a raw edge of the band improvising onstage. There are also alternate and early versions that show how the sound has progressed throughout the years. This helps take away the idea that this edition is just a “cash grab” or “filler,” because every version has substance.
“Wish You Were Here 50” celebrates the anniversary respectfully. The new versions brighten the tracks, and the bonus material adds texture and context. It is a must-have for Pink Floyd connoisseurs, and Dolby Atmos will introduce a younger generation of listeners to the band. My one gripe with it, and to be honest, it is to be expected of them, is that the songs are very long. There are Dolby Atmos versions and live tracks that run over 25 minutes. Pink Floyd connoisseurs will adore it because it shows off the band’s prowess, whereas a casual or new listener may find it a bit too much. There are also long intros, where the first lyrics are sometimes delivered at the 8-minute mark. As for the record, the songs remain the same, but with the element of Dolby Atmos, they have never been more clearer. You hear everything, and it’s glorious.
Song recommendations: ‘Have a Cigar’, ’Shine on You Crazy Diamond (Parts 1-4)’, ‘Wish You Were Here’
The band formed in 1991 and was originally called The Rain after a Beatles b-side from their ‘Paperback Writer’ single. The band was founded in Manchester by Paul ‘Bonehead’ Arthurs (rhythm guitar), Paul ‘Guigsy’ McGuigan (bass), Tony McCarroll (drums and percussion) and Chris Hutton (lead vocalist). Chris didn’t last long and was replaced by Bonehead’s friend Liam Gallagher, who was far from impressed with the band’s name. He said they should change it to Oasis after an Inspiral Carpets poster he had in his room that was a promotional poster for their gig at Oasis Leisure Cente, Swindon. Liam’s middle brother Noel was also the roadie for Inspiral Carpets at the time. That was shortly to change. Noel was in attendance at the band’s debut gig on August 14, 1991, at Manchester’s Boardwalk, where they were at the bottom of the bill, including the Catchmen and Sweet Jesus. The band played songs written by Liam and Bonehead called ‘Take Me’, ‘Alice’ and ‘Reminisce’. Noel felt there was something in the band, even though Liam sounded like The Stone Roses frontman Ian Brown, down to Ian’s famous onstage swagger. Noel then approached the band to give his thoughts. Younger brother Liam asked him if he would like to be their manager.
Noel refused but said he would like to join the band on the condition that he would be the only songwriter and become the leader, and they were dedicated to the band, which would lead to being signed and more. The band agreed to his terms, and Noel went to work first of all by removing the songs written by Liam and Bonehead, only opting to keep ‘Take Me’. He also changed how Bonehead, Guigsy, and Tony played. He got Bonehead to play barre chords, Guigsy to play root bass notes, and Tony to play basic rhythms with the band’s amplifiers turned up to maximum to create distortion. Noel would also take up duties as lead guitarist/backing vocalist. The distorted sound gave them a raw sound that wasn’t being done at the time and gradually got them noticed, especially at King Tut’s Wah Wah Hut, Glasgow, where Alan McGee, the head of Creation, heard them after missing a train to London and went along to see one of his acts. Although ten people were inside the venue, he liked what he heard and approached Noel to see if they were signed. When Noel said “No”, he asked if he wanted a record deal. Noel casually answered, “Yeah. Alright.”
From there, as you will probably be aware, their rise went fucking stratospheric. Their first two albums, “Definitely Maybe” and ” (What’s the Story?) Morning Glory”, would reach the summit and still remain classics. They then played iconic shows like Earls Court 1995, Maine Road 1996 and Knebworth Park. They were always attracting the media’s attention with anything from controversial comments to the Gallagher brothers constant fights and arguments. The band also almost split up several times over issues ranging from poor gig performances to abandoning tours to go house hunting. Band members came and went during their prime and their transitional years. Tony McCarroll was the first to go in 1995, followed by Guigsy briefly in 1995, before returning after Scott McLeod left during the American leg of “(What’s the Story?) Morning Glory? Tour. Guigsy and Bonehead would both depart in 1999. Alan White in 2002, with his brother Steve briefly taking over, Zak Starkey in 2008, and Mike Rowe would leave as the touring keyboardist to be replaced by Kula Shaker’s Jay Darlington. The final lineup would feature Colin ‘Gem’ Archer and Ride’s Andy Bell, who joined in 1999, with Chris Sharrock becoming the drummer in 2008. I don’t really need to go in-depth into what happened at Rock en Seine, Paris, on August 29th 2009. My reviews of Liam Gallagher and Noel Gallagher’s High Flying Birds have more than covered that. The band announced, though, that they were reforming on August 27th this year, with several dates announced for the UK and Ireland leg of their “Live 25” tour, which sold out in minutes.
Further dates are set to be announced for a global tour. The brothers have also done a photo shoot with Simon Emmett this year and reconciled with each other, despite being rumoured to be kept at arm’s length when the tour starts next July. Now that’s done, let’s begin introducing “Definitely Maybe”.
“Definitely Maybe” was released 30 years ago, on August 30th 1994, and the debut album went straight in at No.1. The leading single ‘Supersonic’ released in April , while not breaking the top 20, set the stage for what was to come. Two further singles, including the rather corny ’Shakermaker’ released in June, added to the anticipation. However, it was the release of ‘Live Forever’ three weeks before “Definitely Maybe” that truly made an impact. This now timeless classic, with its optimistic lyrics and melody, was enough to convince people to buy the album. Not forgetting their electrifying promotional tour performances and the controversy surrounding the band, most notably the Gallagher brothers.
“Definitely Maybe” was different from what was on the album chart. It was raw, loud, choc full of lyrics about optimism, and had a punk spirit. Many have labelled the record indie, but I feel it is more punk than anything. The album has no heirs and graces; It is unapologetically loud and in-your-face. A stark contrast to the clean sing-a-longs Blur used for “Parklife”. However, “Definitely Maybe” almost didn’t happen. They booked in Monnow Valley, Wales, in 1993, a time when the music scene was dominated by grunge. Oasis were about to record something completely against the grain. But for some reason, they couldn’t find the energy needed to match Noel’s expectations. They binned off recording there. Noel was utterly unsatisfied. The producer, Dave Batchelor, was a casualty because of this. They then tried again at Sawmills, Cornwall, in January 1994. Recording as if they were performing a gig, with Mark Coyle and Noel producing. Noel was again disillusioned and contacted Alan McGee, saying the album wouldn’t happen. Alan had other ideas, and as he invested a lot of time and money into Oasis, you could see why he took action. Alan hastily contacted engineer and producer Owen Morris. He would get straight to by re-recording some of Liam’s vocals, making Tony’s drum sound more punchy, and removing Noel’s excessive guitar layers.
Owen’s changes would bear fruit, and the guitars and drums were aligned with what Noel wanted. However, apart from Owen saving the day by mixing it at Johnny Marr’s Manchester studio, no one can deny it was the great songwriting of Noel Gallagher that was the real magic behind the songs. He had and does have this knack for writing songs with basic chords, catchy choruses, and meaningful lyrics that are not necessarily poetic but incredibly effective. His lyrics have a way of resonating with the listener, and his melodies draw your attention. You have to see ‘Rock n Roll Star’, ‘Live Forever’, and ’Supersonic’ from the album as evidence.
The band was inspired by The Beatles, The Jam, The Sex Pistols, and cheekily lifted the ‘Bang a Gong (Get it on)’ riff by T. Rex for ‘Cigarettes & Alcohol’ while recording. I have heard many slurs that the band is an inferior version of The Beatles, but I do not share this view and see many of Noel’s influences in the music. “Definitely Maybe”, for me, is more Sex Pistols leaning. I have had many debates about that, but for me, it just is; it embodies the whole punk sound. Now on its 30th anniversary, the record has been released in spatial audio with Dolby Atmos, and if you thought the record sounded great in 1994 or when it was remastered, then this will fucking blow you away. It is beyond amazing. The 30th-anniversary edition also contains:
The original Monnow Valley recordings.
Outtakes from Sawmills.
A Liam on vocals demo of ’Sad Song’.
Now, let’s get on with what you really want. The track-by-track review:
Rock n Roll Star:
Right from the start, it’s a burst of energy. The lyrics echo our deepest desires, and the music whisks us away from the daily grind, offering a comforting respite from life’s challenges. It’s always been a personal favourite, whether I’m listening to the record or experiencing it live.
Shakermaker:
I’m not a particular fan of this one. It is corny, yet at the same time, has a certain charm to it. It is also lifted from the 1971 Coca-Cola jingle I’d Like to Teach the World to Sing (In Perfect Harmony). Here is a little fact: Nowaysis covered both versions. The song is also inspired by elements taken from Noel’s listening preferences- you have “Plasticine” from The Beatles, “Mr Clean” from The Jam and “Mr. Soft” from Cockney Rebel. He also references his local Mancunian record shop, Mr.Sifter. When the band perform this live, they occasionally include an extra verse with the Coca-Cola jingle. Noel was cheeky in how many references he used in this song and was fortunate not to be sued by more than just Coca-Cola Schweppes.
Live Forever:
I absolutely adore this song. It is without hesitation my favourite Oasis song. The lyrics are about wanting to live forever to counter the dark lyrics of the late Kurt Cobain during that period. And who doesn’t want to live forever? In the case of Oasis, they will. They are immortalised with songs like this. This track was the catalyst that led me to pick up the guitar and start writing. While everyone wanted to be Liam, I wanted to be Noel. That guitar solo still sends a shiver down my spine. It may not be the most intricate, but it sold learning to play for me. I feel sorry for Tony, though. In the obligatory video, he is buried before rising again after the guitar rings out. Was this subtle to say he was going to be sacked?
Up in the Sky:
Liam’s vocals are superb, matching the tempo of Noel’s riff. Hearing this live is exactly the same as the studio version. Although, Liam might change the lyrics occasionally.
Columbia:
The track started as an instrumental jam before the lyrics were finally added. The surreal lyrics and sound effects match the psychedelic feel. It’s another personal favourite of mine.
Supersonic:
Noel claims to have written this in ten minutes during the sessions, and a dog called Elsa was present, which led to one of the lyrics. Although I enjoy this from the opening drums, I prefer the live version. Noel goes on a mad one and does an extended outro with a blistering guitar solo. Experiencing this one live is something special. I am still dumbfounded how it didn’t break the top 20 upon its release. It’s a timeless piece of music that we can all appreciate.
Bring it on Down:
This one is definitely punk. You can hear The Sex Pistols. It reminds me a bit of their b-side (Also features on “The Masterplan”) ‘Headshrinker’ without the riff from ’Saturday Night’s Alright (For Fighting)’ being partially lifted. It is just raw, from the guitars down to Liam’s snarling vocals. At one point, I believe he is singing into a megaphone. It certainly is that effect, at least. Tony originally wasn’t grasping this tempo, so Noel hired a session drummer, who also struggled. Then, for some reason, it all clicked for Tony. Originally, this was going to be their debut single. And let me tell you, it’s another barnstormer when performed live, full of energy and excitement.
Cigarettes & Alcohol:
Of course, the riff is lifted from T. Rex’s ‘Bang a Gong (Get it on)’ as mentioned in the introduction section. The song embodies wanting to forget about life and have it while drinking and smoking. It is just uplifting all round. Underneath all the bombastic is quite a political message, but it also says fuck it. Just live it up, drink, smoke and do cocaine. For me, the song doesn’t come alive until the outro. Liam singing that last verse with attitude and a snarl. I also like the guitar solo in the outro.
Digsy’s Dinner:
This is an ode to Noel’s friend Peter ‘Digsy’ Deary from The Sums. Although Digsy is not mentioned in the song, one of Digsy’s anecdotes about lasagna is. It is a short, cheerful, piano-based cheesy sing-a-long. The way Liam elongates “lasagna” is very clever in keeping with the guitar melody but also quite funny. The live performance of this song is where the real excitement lies. It is much better live.
Slide Away:
An ode written to his then-girlfriend. Unfortunately, she left him not long after because she believed he was going nowhere. Ha. The jokes on her. I would describe it as a melancholic love song. Noel recorded this on a Les Paul loaned by Johnny Marr. I love Liam’s sustained vocals on the chorus. The song is great, but you know the genuine emotion behind it when it’s stripped back.
Married with Children:
Noel was writing and a the television show sharing the same name as the title happened to be on. The song itself centres on pettiness when sharing a home with a lover. I have had debates over Liam’s current vocals, and how they have declined, and when they ask “why?”, I point them in the direction of this stripped back track. His vocals are angelic and on point. Many have said Liam is a monotone vocalist, but I refute that when you hear this. Liam at his very best.
Overall:
How do I write this? I’ve already lauded the album countless times within the review. You can understand why it is considered the favourite Oasis record for many, including myself. Noel has mentioned he loves it and has been playing it constantly on its 30th anniversary. “Definitely Maybe” is about escaping the usual shit we face and longing for a better life with sprinkles of optimism. An exquisite sound hides the melancholic lyrics (sometimes cheerful). The record also signified what was to come for Oasis. All of these songs are brilliant live. It was strange, yet pleasing to hear ‘Married with Children’ electric. I may not have touched much on where the punk is on the album. It’s all over. From the defiant lyrics and punk rock instrumentation to Liam’s snarling. I don’t know what to say if you cannot hear that in songs like ‘Rock n Roll Star’. There is a reason this record has stood the test of time. I don’t think I will ever tire of listening to it. It’s apt that a record that inspired hope 30 years ago has returned to the summit as we are now back in the same political situation. We need something to raise our spirits and return to feeling hopeful.
Song recommendations: ‘Live Forever’, ‘Rock n Roll Star’, ‘Married with Children’
As you know, the Stone Roses guitarist John Squire joined Oasis onstage in 1996 at their iconic Knebworth Park shows to play lead on ‘Champagne Supernova’. He also repeated this on Liam’s return to the venue as a solo artist in 2022. Back when John was rehearsing the song with Liam, John mentioned that he was in the process of writing an album and needed a vocalist. He said that Liam’s vocals would be ideal, and from there, Liam listened to the demos and decided he would be interested in collaborating with John. Liam grew up a Stone Roses fan, and in the earlier Oasis recordings, his vocals sounded like Ian Brown. The duo would head over to Los Angeles to record the self-titled album in the studio.
Of course, the project only came to light during the first month of the new year, when the duo released their first single, ‘Just Another Rainbow’ —a typical Stone Roses-esque song.
Once it was confirmed that the duo was releasing a record, Liam described it as Stone Roses and Oasis in their prime. When you listen to the album, that is certainly evident. As you can imagine, there are many Beatles, Rolling Stones, The Who, et cetera, within the songs because those bands heavily influenced both of them.
As well as being a nostalgic record filled with romance, there are modern references in songs like ‘I’m So Bored’, where John attacks modern technology, expressing that we tend to live in our phones rather than connecting with the real world.
You can tell Liam and John had fun on the album, with Greg Kurstin on production. Many Liam’s fans complain about it not being full-on rock n roll. It was never meant to be. Stones Roses are more psychedelic, so this would always lean heavily towards that. Apart from finding the lyrics cheesy, I also found them quite basic, and Liam’s vocals feel strained and nasal over the music. John is excellent as always and has retained his ability to show his axemanship. It wasn’t my cup of green tea, but good luck to them.
Song recommendations: ‘Mars to Liverpool’, ‘Just Another Rainbow’, ‘I’m So Bored’
This opening song lets the listener know that the album will tell a story as it progresses, with the Beatles accompanying Sgt.Pepper along the way.
With a Little Help from My Friends:
The most famous version of this is by the Scottish band, Wet, Wet, Wet in the early 1990s. Anyway, onto the song. For a change, it is drummer Ringo Starr who takes lead vocals, but not to try to appease the drummer’s fans. This is one of the most uplifting songs ever made by anyone, and here is a fact for you about the mid-tempo groover; it is still performed currently in Ringo’s live shows.
Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds:
Well, this is psychedelic rock with a Beatles twist. Even though the song suggests that it might be about the psychedelic drug known as LSD, there is a strong rumour that John actually wrote it about his son, Julian, after he brought home a picture from nursery (I think.), which had a sky featuring diamonds. John thought that would make an excellent subject for a song. As for “Lucy”? That remains a mystery, but it could have been used for rhyming purposes.
Getting Better:
A double-edge to this track, indeed. On the one hand, it might be very relaxed and let the listener drift off into space, but on the other hand, the song paints a bleak picture of a man who beats his woman up, but he is getting better at cutting this out for good and learning to treat her right.
Fixing a Hole:
Definitely a very psychedelic moment here. What a weird and fucked up story, indeed. It’s basically about the narrator, who is surrounded by people just minding his business and concentrating on fixing his hole, not for anyone’s benefit, but his own.
She’s Leaving Home:
This track talks about the growing generation gap back in that decade when children left home in droves. The track is cloaked with angelic string sections that take the edge off how the story speaks from a family point of view about their daughter leaving home, which makes the family broken.
Being for the Benefit of Mr Kite!:
This can only be described as psychedelic rock and classical combined or, metaphorically, like looking through a kaleidoscope and seeing all kinds of beautifully coloured shapes.
Within You Without You:
A track that draws inspiration from traditional Indian music, and it comes as no surprise that it was written by lead guitarist George Harrison who learnt how to play the sitar with the legendary Ravi Shankar.
When I’m Sixty-Four:
Written by bassist Paul McCartney, this song is very much on the charm offensive, which Paul is so adept at. Although he mentions grandchildren called Vera, Chuck and Dave (sounds like something out of Coronation Street, doesn’t it?), he has no grandchildren with those names.
Lovely Rita:
This is about having a crush on a meter maid (Do you have to ask her name?) and drinking tea.
Good Morning Good Morning:
Ah, another song about this particular time of day makes its way onto a Beatles record. We’ve had “Here Comes the Sun” and “Good Day Sunshine”, to name a few. The most bizarre thing that makes this track stand out is a dog barking on the outro. Fuck knows what that has to do with the morning (dog barking at passers-by or the mail delivery person, maybe?).
Sgt.Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise):
This can only be described as the calm before the storm finale—very much an interlude section.
A Day in the Life:
Well, it came as no surprise that on a Psychedelic record, the Beatles would close it with a song about drugs that was written, composed and arranged at the height of what was known as the swinging ’60s. Still, the sound and the vision, which are so fantastic and luxurious, doesn’t bind it to its era. Just like the whole record, it has stood the test of time.
Overall:
I am not a fan of the Beatles, although I probably am indirectly as I am of Oasis, who made it no secret that the Beatles inspired them and let’s not forget that I also like playing Beatles on the guitar. I also like hearing Paul McCartney perform live and am a big fan of John Lennon’s solo material. I feel robbed in that; my generation and generations that will follow missed the opportunity to hear what the Beatles would have sounded like with modern technology (If it was anything like Oasis did then, to quote Noel Gallagher, “Fucking mega!”). Maybe then, I would become a fan, but I have seen all their films and appreciate the marker they laid down for the bands that followed them. I respect their work and chief songwriters, Paul McCartney and John Lennon. Despite not being a fan, I really do like this record, and the re-mastering done by Giles Martin (His father, George Martin was the original arranger of the record and did work with the likes of Oasis) does bring this record to life and into the new age. He certainly does his father and the legacy of the Beatles utter justice. I rate this one of my favourite records of all time, and the eccentric sleeve adds to the vibrant nature. Since I was a child, that sleeve stood out to me. Fifty years on from its original release, the record is still talked about in high regard and upon its re-release, it was no surprise that the album utterly destroyed the competition to sit on top of the charts proving that even in the present day, the Beatles still have a seismic fanbase to topple the formidable, Ed Sheeran.
Honest Opinions 