Week 20: Florence and the Machine- Dance Fever

Florence and the Machine started as a duo in 2007, with Florence Welch on vocals and Isabella Summers on keyboards. They were initially called Florence Robot/Isa Machine before changing the name to Florence is a Machine before their first gig. Eventually, they settled on Florence and the Machine and turned it into a band rather than a duo. 

However, most mistaken the band as Florence’s solo project as the group bears her name. It would help if they said it sounds like a duo because Isabella is “the Machine”. I have heard many accounts where “the Machine” has been mistaken for Florence’s backing band. I first heard Florence and the Machine via a friend’s iTunes playlist in late 2008. I had never heard of the band, and he had ‘Rabbit Heart(Raise it up)’ on this playlist. I was instantly impressed with Florence’s vocal range on the track. Alas, I was disappointed with Florence’s live vocals when I saw them live at Glastonbury, iTunes, Oxygen, and Reading/Leeds that year. Don’t get me wrong, I still enjoyed the music, but those notes she hit on ‘Rabbit Heart(Raise it up)’ were far from what I heard on the studio version.

I don’t intend to make this a long review for their latest album, “Dance Fever”, because I am not sold on it. Plenty of the tracks have long intros or outros, making me think they plan on doing another short film as they did for their 2015 record “How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful”. I prefer that album to this. “Dance Fever” was made over the past two years during lockdown. From what I gathered, the record focuses on mental health, and Florence details it like talking to a therapist. This isn’t my reason for not liking it. The intros and outros were far too long.

The production is tame to what you have come to have known Florence and the Machine for. The production is split between Jack Antonoff and Dave Bayley. It is hard to write about one song because they seem to crash into each other. I enjoyed the bonus disc that featured four songs off the standard version acoustically and a track called ‘Search and Destroy’, which for me was the best track of the entire album, but it is a cover of the Stooges song.


Song recommendations: ‘Search and Destroy’, ‘Cassandra’, ‘Free’




6/10

Week Forty-One: Liam Gallagher- As You Were

Liam_Gallagher_-_As_You_Were

 Of course, we will never forget what happened in Paris at Rock en Seine Festival minutes before Oasis were due on stage to play one of their last three gigs (I think.), it was left to Bloc Party’s Kele Okereke to announce to the crowd that, Oasis had split up on that August bank holiday night in 2009. What happened? We’ve heard both sides of the story from both Gallagher Brothers, but the others who could give us an insight have so far refused to talk about it, albeit very vaguely. Like most of us, I was shocked and gutted that Oasis was no more, but I could see it coming from the three gigs I attended on their final tour (For now. Will they reform? I can’t see it.). Especially at the iTunes Festival, where Liam seemed in an extremely foul mood, you could see the apparent tension between the Brothers. 

Anyway, what happened next was Beady Eye (Fronted by Liam with the rest of what was Oasis.) in 2009 and Noel Gallagher’s High Flying Birds( A solo project, apparently.) in 2010 were formed. Beady Eye’s debut record, “Different Gear, Still Speeding”, did very well, and although I wasn’t that keen on it, I did like three songs off it. Unfortunately, they couldn’t build on the success of the debut record and had a very indifferent second album, “BE”, which left Liam very disheartened and made him decide to split Beady Eye up after the tour. 

While this happened, his brother had a successful period with Noel Gallagher’s High Flying Birds. So what was next for Liam? After making the odd cameo appearance in 2014 and 2015, he headed back into the studio to record his debut album, “As You Were”, and I’m not going to hold back, so I apologise if anyone reading this doesn’t like it. I will go into these things later in the review about what I mean.

Liam isn’t trying to head in any other direction than what Oasis fans expected from the younger brother. “Wall of Glass” was the taster off the album back in June, and I heard it everywhere. Though I liked the energy and the attitude in the track, I cringed at the guitar riff at the intro and between the verses. It ruined for me what could have been a very good song. As we get to “Greedy Soul”, it is quite obvious who this is directed at, even if Liam refuses to admit it. The lyrics alone are a clue. “You’re getting told, you greedy soul, you’ve been telling lies, you’re a slippery kind”. It’s either Noel or Liam’s sister-in-law, Sara MacDonald, with whom he has had many a public spat via social media and, of course, in private.

“For What It’s Worth” seems an apology to Noel soaked in Beatles-inspired music from the 1968 record, “the White Album”. It sounds a bit like “Hey Jude”, in my opinion. The next was one I found very surprising, considering that Liam promised a “Rock out with your chin out” record and “Chinatown” does not fit into this premise. It’s a bouncy melody played with an acoustic guitar where Liam talks about taking you through the streets of Chinatown.

“You Better Run” and “Paper Crown” were the best of a bad bunch. “I’ve All I Need” that ends the album suggests that this could be an egotistical song judging by the title, but it is not. It is a song of gratitude to his fans and, I imagine, his family and friends. It’s a tranquil and sincere ending to a record that was supposed to be a “Rock out with your chin out” album. I did like the final track, but it doesn’t remind me of the attitude of Liam. He did write some acoustic songs with Oasis, even though he declared acoustic songs as “shite” or something along those lines. He even loathed doing intimate acoustic gigs for Oasis.

Overall: I was very disappointed with the debut record by Liam. Especially after hearing, “It’s a rock out with your chin out record”. I had high expectations after watching Liam’s warm-up gigs. Still, after the first single, “Wall of Glass”, I felt we might be heading into the “mediocre” direction which we have, unfortunately. For me, Liam has not been vocally strong since 2003. Anytime after, I have found his delivery; although the raw emotion is still there, the voice is shot to pieces, and he sounds nasally and croaky. Almost like he has lost his voice from shouting too much; of course, the parka monkeys would argue the toss with me, but there’s no denying his voice is past its best. Liam has also been very naïve with this record and let the producers interfere too much with the sound. I find that quite odd when you consider him a guy who won’t be bullied or told what to do. Was he being naïve in the studio, or is it simply the fact he has never been in this position to take charge of what direction he wanted? It could be both, but there has certainly been meddling, and I can’t see that Liam wanted the record to sound like this entirely. He will learn his lesson next time to ensure none of this meddling. He has employed an army of songwriters to aid him because he hasn’t written anything good since “I’m Outta Time” for Oasis in 2008. It’s quite sad that his voice sounds great on this record, but you can make the worst singer in the world sound like an angel with the technology available on the mixing desks and software. Unfortunately, you cannot dress up vocals to that degree live, and Liam’s vocals have been absent since 2003. I wish him well, and he will have several fans as he did with Oasis and Beady Eye, regardless of how they view his vocal performance live. 5/10