Once again, this is another cliché. I found this band via Later…with Jools Holland, where they performed ‘Nothing Matters’ and ‘ My Lady of Mercy’. From there, I scoured YouTube, looking for information about them. I came across a review of one of their tracks, plus a little background on them by The Darkness frontman Justin Hawkins. He does a review show on there called Justin Hawkins Rides Again. It has become so popular that he is taking it out on the road. I was highly impressed with his knowledge of every tone in the track. He also mentioned that the band are rumoured to be “industry plants”. Now, if they are, who cares? You can tell they are highly talented, so they would inevitably break through regardless. This rumour is circulating because the band had minimal performances before being signed. Skunk Anansie must have been “industry plants” if that’s the case. They were signed after four gigs. That’s how ridiculous this rumour is for me. I am sure Skunk Anansie was in the right place at the right time. The other suspicions are that they also signed to the prestigious Island Records, have over 30 million streams for ‘Nothing Matters’ on Spotify, and have had this album produced by James Ford, who has recently worked with Blur, Kylie Minogue, and Arctic Monkeys on their current records.
So, a little background on the band: They are from London. An all-female rock band (I beg to differ on rock.)consisting of Abigail Morris (Leading vocalist), Lizzie Mayland (Backing vocalist, guitarist, flautist), Emily Roberts (Guitarist, backing vocalist, flautist, mandolin), Georgia Davies (Bassist, backing vocalist), and Aurora Nishevci (Backing vocalist, organist, synthesiser, conductor, string arranger). I believe they also met at university, which is another reason people are suspicious of their rise. Fuck knows what that has to do with it. I like the name of the album, and I found the cover art quite eye-catching. The name might have a negative impact because it mentions a specific substance that also has taken its name from a form of joy. As everyone knows, I detest preludes/interludes, but there was a certain magic to them this time. There are two interludes. The title track and ‘Gjuha’, with the latter coming in just after the halfway point. Both tracks feature incredible vocal harmonies over what can only be described as booming classical music. From the reading, there is no clear indication that an orchestra was used, but it sounded like one in the prelude/interlude. You must admire the sheer audacity of using such music when this album was released in the mainstream. From this, you can tell that the ladies do not want to conform.
The band reminds me of a cross between Florence and the Machine and Elastica. Because of their sound, but also, Abigail sounds similar to Justine Frischmann. Talking of Abigail, her best vocal performance is ‘On Your Side’. However, that doesn’t take away from the other tracks. She is an outstanding vocalist.
The highlight has to be ‘Caesar on a TV Screen’. It changes throughout with different genres and tempos. Quite a lot of the tracks stop suddenly, but after half a minute, they come back in with frantic tempos, usually classical or a stabbing piano. The title of the record is quite apt. There are many moments of ecstasy. I was left highly impressed. It is pretty hard to believe that this is only a debut album.
Song recommendations: ‘Caesar on a TV Screen’, ‘On Your Side’, ‘My Lady of Mercy’
have no idea where I first heard Robbie Williams. Take That appeared out of nowhere in the 90s and became extremely popular without a steady rise. I don’t mind some of Robbie’s work since he decided to go solo in 1997, which started with the indie-inspired ‘Old Before I Die’. I love that song, but Robbie isn’t too keen on it when you read his 2016 autobiography “Reveal”. He appears to hate it with a passion. I used to love hearing it on the radio, on television or on the jukebox at the local Riley’s snooker club. It epitomised the whole indie revival movement during that period. I am surprised by his submission because after being discarded by the Gallagher brothers, he said in his book, it didn’t deter him from liking Oasis, and he enjoys a lot of indie music. I don’t fucking care if some of you are smirking at me reading his book, it was an intriguing read, and you get to know the honest Robbie and not the one slaughtered by the media. So, my initial plan was to listen to the new tracks on “XXV”, but he had other ideas. Yes, it is his greatest hits, but not in their original guise. The songs have been reimagined with Jules Buckley conducting an orchestra, and there is even a Beethoven version of ‘Angels’. That’s the introduction over; now to the review. I have elected to analyse each classic and new song track-by-track.
Let’s begin:
Let Me Entertain You:
No one can forget this beast of an anthem with its rock attitude. When this was recorded, the La’s and Lightning Seeds drummer Chris Sharrock was drumming for Robbie. Of course, Chris would go on to join Robbie’s friends Oasis, Beady Eye, and his least favourite Gallagher brother Noel Gallagher’s High Flying Birds. The song carries on in the same vein, but the horns and choir bring that celestial finish to it. Already I am impressed.
Come Undone:
A friend had this on a Now That’s What I Call Music compilation in 2003, and I was reading the footnotes. Tupac Shakur inspires this song. I was shocked to hear this because I don’t hear any references to Pac in the song. On a side note, Robbie and Pac met in 1995 at the Versace birthday party. They both shared a joint, and they got on almost immediately. Pac didn’t know about Robbie’s portrayal by the media and didn’t seem to care either. They shot the shit about life and, for a brief moment, became friends. Has the song improved much since the original? Only slightly. Not much to write about.
Love my Life:
In the book, Robbie said he wrote this for Theodora(his daughter.) to tell her never to forget to love your life despite what others might say about you. Again, the orchestra lift this song to another level; to be honest; it is fit for the West End when they do a musical on Robbie.
Millenium:
There was no point in tweaking this track. It doesn’t enhance it, as the original already has a stringed section. I believe it was pilfered from a James Bond theme song. He was better off not bothering to rework this one.
the Road to Mandalay:
Again, a pointless rework. The original is better.
Tripping:
For the third time in succession, the track didn’t need necessary work. I am sure this one catches your attention by starting off with a reggae vibe before returning to the familiarity. You feel cheated when the reggae falls away after the introduction. I’d have preferred a reggae vibe on the rework, in all honesty. I cannot recall a single track where Robbie has done reggae.
Bodies:
I’ve never been a fan of it, and the rework didn’t do much for me.
Candy:
Jesus. This song made me cringe when it came out, and still makes me cringe now. Robbie is better than bubblegum pop.
Supreme:
Again, I believe another song pilfered from a James Bond film. I didn’t feel a rework was necessary. I mean, what could Jules have possibly done to improve it? The original has an orchestra. There are, however, female backing vocals. Still didn’t do much to improve, though.
Strong:
Again, Robbie puts on his indie head in the original, and to be honest, there is not much difference between the XXV version and the original. It’s a photo finish which is better.
Eternity:
Just like ‘Strong’, there isn’t much difference in both versions.
No Regrets:
My favourite track off “I’ve Been Expecting You”, and it has to be the original that will remain my favourite. He tries to make this more upbeat when the original is melancholic, which fits with the concept.
She’s the One:
I love this cover of World Party’s track, even though the original is much better. It was a nice nod to World Party, but Karl Wallinger has said on many occasions he now hates performing the song and that Robbie ruined it for him. In the book, Robbie mentions how through a third party, Karl said, “When you see him, tell him he’s a cunt”. If Karl hated the original cover, he isn’t going to be too fond of the XXV version, either. However, I believe the majority will agree with him this time.
Feel:
I was not too fond of it then, didn’t like it when Peter Schmeichel played on it live, and I still don’t like it now.
Rock DJ:
When this came out in the summer of 2000, I liked it. Then, it was played to death, so I stopped listening to it, and as I got older, I could not stand it. Even listening to the rework was too much.
Kids:
I loved this when it came out in the autumn of 2000, with its rock attitude and the collaboration with Kylie Minogue. Kylie features in the rework. Again, a photo finish of which one is best.
Angels:
The original pisses all over this. Do look out for a surprise later on, though.
Lost:
Now, we have come to a brand new track. It was made for this album. Yes, I know it was actually made for this record, but what I mean is it’s a perfect fit. The orchestra musicians compliment each other.
Nobody Someday:
An acoustic guitar accompanies Robbie’s vocals, accompanied by a soft choir. A vast improvement on the original.
Lazy Days:
The original itself was lazy instrumentally and vocally. The rework brings it to life—the orchestra playing a pivotal role.
Hot Fudge:
I never liked it and still don’t.
Sexed up:
Again, I wouldn’t say I liked the original, and my concentration wavered on this one.
More than This:
Another brand new song. Once again, it is a perfect fit, just like ‘Lost’.
Disco Symphony:
Another new track that does exactly what it says. I can see this one being played at parties and wedding receptions imminently. Very uptempo and very disco.
Better Man:
You’re better off listening to the original.
Home Thoughts from Abroad:
The Magic FM moment on the album. Although to be fair, the majority of the record will fit nicely on their playlists.
the World and Her Mother:
The final new track has the Robbie signature written all over it.
Into the Silence:
Again, another photo finish.
Angels (Beethoven AI):
This song is merged with Beethoven’s ‘Unfinished 10th Symphony’, and fuck me; it fits in perfectly. I never thought I would see the day when ‘Angels’ collaborates with ‘Unfinished 10th Symphony’. I was blown away when I heard it, and it fucking destroys the original. That was a very clever move by Robbie. This version is beyond space; it’s that good.
Song recommendations: ‘Angels(Beethoven AI)’, ‘Nobody Someday’, ‘Disco Symphony’
7/10
Why such an average rating, you ask? Well, because I prefer the originals.
Now, I haven’t been that keen on Lady Gaga ever since “Poker Face”, “Bad Romance”, “Born This Way”, and “Alejandro”, which are considered the best of her songs. Oh, and that one featured in that “A Star is Born” film. I changed my mind about the 21st-century Madonna after hearing her duet with the great Tony Bennett. After hearing that, it showed me that she was more than just a generic yet eccentric pop star. She did shine for me on those recordings and gained some of my respect.
Indeed, she is versatile in her fashion and music and has probably outperformed her predecessor, Madonna, in the art of shock. Remember that Gaga has been inside an egg down the red carpet and worn a dress made entirely of beef. She has done jazz, as I mentioned, with the great Tony Bennett, which, for me, was the turning point in bringing her music to those who can’t stand generic pop and appealing to a much more mature audience. She made a country-themed album which is entirely about her auntie, who died before she was born, and then she branched out into film, where she did the soundtrack and was the lead role in 2018’s “A Star is Born”. Some may compare her to being similar to the late David Bowie, but although I agree, I still stand by my stance of her being a Madonna for the new millennium.
Some critics have said that “Chromatica” is her return to form and is more in line with her pop music, but I will have to disagree with them as I found the record was laced with 1990s house. While making notes for her sixth album, this is what I discovered:
Three short songs make up “Chromatica”, just stringed instrumentals resembling something you hear at the Albert Hall in London during the Proms, so basically classical, but certainly ideal for the big screen and the big classical music halls. Some have described ” Alice ” as disco, but I wholly disagree. This ode to Alice in Wonderland is very much house from the 1990s. One critic described it as her take on garage, which left me entirely surprised.
“Stupid Love” is your typical Lady Gaga song and sounds like “Born This Way.” “Rain on Me”, which features former teenage actress Ariana Grande, sounds like the sort of track that Mylo or Diplo would produce. “Free Woman” sent me right back to those 1990 raves (Although for me, it was more raving at School discos, parties and youth clubs.) with its substantial house bound production. “Plastic Doll” seems to be a warning to any male who wants to mess her about and treat her like shit, “Sour Candy” features Blackpink, which is aptly named and yet another track inspired by house.
“Enigma” is house with its classic piano riff and very soulful vocals and is perfect for when the clubs eventually open their doors again, “Replay” uses a sample from a Calvin Harris hit of which I can’t remember the name (It goes, “ooh, ooh ooh, ooh ooh, ooh, ooh” if that helps?) “1000 Doves” is yet another track that takes inspiration from the 1990s club scene with a piano wrapped around dance beats and electronic drums. You may wonder why I haven’t included the song with Elton John. The reason for that is that, disappointingly, Elton opts for autotune rather than using his natural vocal ability. The final song I will touch on, which closes the album, is the Madonna-esque “Babylon”, which, to me, is the 21st-century version of “Vogue”, with Lady Gaga even using spoken word like Madonna did on her 1990s hit. It even has that classic piano riff from “Vogue.” the only thing that doesn’t feature is the strings, but unlike Madonna’s song, Gaga’s has a beautiful saxophone solo.
This opening song lets the listener know that the album will tell a story as it progresses, with the Beatles accompanying Sgt.Pepper along the way.
With a Little Help from My Friends:
The most famous version of this is by the Scottish band, Wet, Wet, Wet in the early 1990s. Anyway, onto the song. For a change, it is drummer Ringo Starr who takes lead vocals, but not to try to appease the drummer’s fans. This is one of the most uplifting songs ever made by anyone, and here is a fact for you about the mid-tempo groover; it is still performed currently in Ringo’s live shows.
Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds:
Well, this is psychedelic rock with a Beatles twist. Even though the song suggests that it might be about the psychedelic drug known as LSD, there is a strong rumour that John actually wrote it about his son, Julian, after he brought home a picture from nursery (I think.), which had a sky featuring diamonds. John thought that would make an excellent subject for a song. As for “Lucy”? That remains a mystery, but it could have been used for rhyming purposes.
Getting Better:
A double-edge to this track, indeed. On the one hand, it might be very relaxed and let the listener drift off into space, but on the other hand, the song paints a bleak picture of a man who beats his woman up, but he is getting better at cutting this out for good and learning to treat her right.
Fixing a Hole:
Definitely a very psychedelic moment here. What a weird and fucked up story, indeed. It’s basically about the narrator, who is surrounded by people just minding his business and concentrating on fixing his hole, not for anyone’s benefit, but his own.
She’s Leaving Home:
This track talks about the growing generation gap back in that decade when children left home in droves. The track is cloaked with angelic string sections that take the edge off how the story speaks from a family point of view about their daughter leaving home, which makes the family broken.
Being for the Benefit of Mr Kite!:
This can only be described as psychedelic rock and classical combined or, metaphorically, like looking through a kaleidoscope and seeing all kinds of beautifully coloured shapes.
Within You Without You:
A track that draws inspiration from traditional Indian music, and it comes as no surprise that it was written by lead guitarist George Harrison who learnt how to play the sitar with the legendary Ravi Shankar.
When I’m Sixty-Four:
Written by bassist Paul McCartney, this song is very much on the charm offensive, which Paul is so adept at. Although he mentions grandchildren called Vera, Chuck and Dave (sounds like something out of Coronation Street, doesn’t it?), he has no grandchildren with those names.
Lovely Rita:
This is about having a crush on a meter maid (Do you have to ask her name?) and drinking tea.
Good Morning Good Morning:
Ah, another song about this particular time of day makes its way onto a Beatles record. We’ve had “Here Comes the Sun” and “Good Day Sunshine”, to name a few. The most bizarre thing that makes this track stand out is a dog barking on the outro. Fuck knows what that has to do with the morning (dog barking at passers-by or the mail delivery person, maybe?).
Sgt.Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise):
This can only be described as the calm before the storm finale—very much an interlude section.
A Day in the Life:
Well, it came as no surprise that on a Psychedelic record, the Beatles would close it with a song about drugs that was written, composed and arranged at the height of what was known as the swinging ’60s. Still, the sound and the vision, which are so fantastic and luxurious, doesn’t bind it to its era. Just like the whole record, it has stood the test of time.
Overall:
I am not a fan of the Beatles, although I probably am indirectly as I am of Oasis, who made it no secret that the Beatles inspired them and let’s not forget that I also like playing Beatles on the guitar. I also like hearing Paul McCartney perform live and am a big fan of John Lennon’s solo material. I feel robbed in that; my generation and generations that will follow missed the opportunity to hear what the Beatles would have sounded like with modern technology (If it was anything like Oasis did then, to quote Noel Gallagher, “Fucking mega!”). Maybe then, I would become a fan, but I have seen all their films and appreciate the marker they laid down for the bands that followed them. I respect their work and chief songwriters, Paul McCartney and John Lennon. Despite not being a fan, I really do like this record, and the re-mastering done by Giles Martin (His father, George Martin was the original arranger of the record and did work with the likes of Oasis) does bring this record to life and into the new age. He certainly does his father and the legacy of the Beatles utter justice. I rate this one of my favourite records of all time, and the eccentric sleeve adds to the vibrant nature. Since I was a child, that sleeve stood out to me. Fifty years on from its original release, the record is still talked about in high regard and upon its re-release, it was no surprise that the album utterly destroyed the competition to sit on top of the charts proving that even in the present day, the Beatles still have a seismic fanbase to topple the formidable, Ed Sheeran.
The introduction is upbeat, with a bouncy piano riff and a harmonising female vocalist. I felt warm inside listening to the track and its jazz feel. It feels like something out of a Broadway show or, as I live in England, a theatre show from London’s West End. It’ll certainly get you all dancing. The song ends with a big fanfare, which grows into some car horns.
Someone in the Crowd:
This certainly feels like I am watching a show in the theatre, and I can see many smiling faces around me moving their body and head along to the music. This song also seems inspired by Coldplay’s “Viva La Vida”, and I can hear Chris Martin’s vocals in my head as it bops along to the melody. The breakdown is very sudden and will take You by surprise during mid-song. This is followed by what appears to be clarinets; the trumpets kick in before an array of vocalists can be heard to close the song out.
Mia and Sebastian’s Theme:
A sweet and delicate piano playing introduces (kind of like the ambience You would find in a restaurant to further your experience and enjoy your meal). This is very short and ends with slightly more pace.
A Lovely Night:
The first thing I feel when I hear this is that I am floating on a cloud. Again, a very relaxed song that puts a smile on your face and gets you lost in the moment. I got a sense of Chris Rea’s “Driving Home for Christmas” when I heard this. I love the orchestra; that compliments the jazz piano well. Dare I say it; there’s a slight hint of mild Drum n Bass in this.
Herman’s Habit:
The introduction has a jazzy feel with the Buddy Rich-esque drumming accompanied by trumpets, piano and saxophone. This wouldn’t sound out of place at Ronny Scott’s or the Jazz Café in Camden. Too short for my liking, though. You don’t get a chance to get into it.
City of Stars:
This starts as if it is a lullaby and features the vocals of actor Ryan Gosling. His delivery is done with such conviction that it makes the listener believe he means every word he is projecting with his voice.
Planetarium:
A sweet clarinet accompanied by the harpsichord introduces this song and throughout. It makes me think I’m watching a play somewhere in Italy. After the break, the orchestra takes full effect bringing a very classical element.
Summer Montage/Madeline:
Again, back to the jazz that has featured heavily on this album. I enjoyed this song, albeit it was a short instrumental.
City of Stars:
Part two is with both cast members, Ryan Gosling and Emma Stone. This song is unique from part one because Emma’s accidental giggle made the final version. When they both sing simultaneously, they appear to be synchronised, which shows that these actors can also sing correctly.
Start a Fire:
The only track written on the album by a man that has been around (at least mainstream) since 2005, John Legend and more than deserves his legendary status despite his short time in the mainstream (I would say that 12 years is relatively short compared to most of the legendary music icons). The introduction features an audience cheering and whooping, welcoming the beginning bars of John’s vocals. This has a typical John Legend feel, complete with backing female vocals. There is even space for a synthesiser solo. His lyrics touch on starting a fire in the sense that their relationship (I’m assuming this is some romantic film) can be more than just standard and that they can show pure love and devotion to one another. He could also be talking about passionate lovemaking.
Engagement Party:
The song title suggests that the romance has reached a whole new level, and one has proposed. This song is likely featured at an engagement party they have put on at their house or some other venue—a short piano riff.
Audition (the Fools who Dream):
The introduction is a spoken dialogue by Emma Stone before turning into delicate vocals accompanied by a piano and then later by a full Orchestra. The lyrics mention various expressive arts occupations and a nod to the dreamers, no matter how unrealistic or difficult it might be to achieve their ultimate goal.
Epilogue:
This is one of the most extended tracks heading towards the album’s end. It features snippets of all the songs I have heard so far.
the End:
The shortest song on the album (a mere 46 seconds) features piano, strings and a celestial choir.
City of Stars(Humming):
This is the third and final part of the song that features Emma harmonising with her humming throughout (except towards the end, she decides to “ba” and “dah”) with a plucked acoustic guitar.
Overall:
I have no knowledge (Nor care) of what the film is about; I only reviewed this album as it was number one in the charts. Nonetheless, I enjoyed the soundtrack and moved my head along with the music. I have a very eclectic taste in music, and I love this album’s jazz and classical feel. I still won’t watch the film as it is not my preference, but I would definitely listen to this soundtrack again. All the songs were great, and the actors also did a good job with their vocals, not to mention it had a very West End production aura. Even if the film is not your thing, I recommend listening to the soundtrack regardless. 8/10
Honest Opinions 