Boygenius are a rock supergroup formed in 2018 consisting of Julien Baker, Lucy Dacus, and Phoebe Bridgers. The former is the only one I have ever heard of, and I enjoy most of her material. Five years ago, the band also released their self-titled EP. They share common ground, and what makes Boygenius dynamic is their similar tastes in authors and poets. There is more than just a love of music, and unlike most supergroups, this has been formed on music and other passions to make the chemistry extra special. They also have their unique style of writing. Julien Baker is more melancholic, whereas Phoebe Bridgers, although she can sing softly, brings more energy, and Lucy Dacus brings consciousness to the fore.
Here is my track-by-track review of “the Record”:
Without You Without Them:
The opening track begins with the trio singing acapella. The trio exchanging cyphers.
$20:
This has Julien Baker written all over it (Although I only know of Phoebe’s work, I did a little listening research.), where she gets political and her watermark guitar riffs, which, when you listen to her work, your ear picks up on the familiarity. Of course, as it is a trio, Lucy and Phoebe find a space on the track, with Bridgers doing a 90s-esque grunge rock scream, and Dacus leads the line during the fast tempo and fleshy verses.
Emily, I’m Sorry:
This song is split into two parts. The song title doesn’t fit the narrative that you should expect it to. Instead of being an audio apology letter to a specific individual, it discusses how uncertain life was during the pandemic ( depending on where you live.). You can hear Phoebe’s solo work coming through, but it also shows Boygenius working together to give it that unique sound.
True Blue:
This is quite obviously the turn of Lucy again. Why? Because her vocals are at the forefront, whereas Julien and Phoebe’s are more muted. This track is mellow and mid-tempo compared to what has happened so far. You can tell the band work democratically.
Cool About it:
We finally get to the acoustic song on the album with a cameo appearance from the banjo. The track could be described as folk-rock. Each member exchanges a cypher with different variations of bumping into the dreaded ex. The cyphers showcase just how talented each individual is at songwriting.
Not Strong Enough:
Just listening to this, you can tell that Sheryl Crow heavily influenced the trio. The track discusses the hotbed issue of the treatment of women (to this day, unfortunately.) within the industry. The instrumentation itself goes back to the sound more akin to ‘$20’ before developing into something more uplifting, which creates a rush of blood in your body. Synths feature on the bridge, and the strumming of the guitar with effects gives it that indie blend. I can imagine this one doing quite well on the tour. Although the lyrics are blunt, there is a sense of this becoming a tour anthem.
Revolution 0:
Another tender acoustic ballad to welcome in the second half of the album. The song has a frustrated delivery by Phoebe to match the writing. Phoebe ponders what love is and why it is called that if it isn’t love.
Leonard Cohen:
Well, this is one of the favourite poets they all adore. The late Leonard Cohen was one of the best poets around. There is a nod to one of his tracks from 1992 called ‘the Anthem’. The track is, funnily enough, the shortest on the album, but in no terms does it mean they are insulting his memory. The band discuss the song’s meaning, which is about accepting your own imperfections. Lucy also has an Easter Egg in her verse, so listen out for that. Clue: It has already featured on the album.
Satanist:
This track features dirty and heavy riffs as Phoebe lets out a scream you will hear in many grunge songs. The track changes tempo again after the instrumental break after the bridge with Julien’s question about satanism as the song changes to downtempo and absent of guitars.
We’re in Love:
Phoebe has been taking over a bit with her songs, but Lucy steps up this time, showcasing her ability to write a specific feeling and deliver it on the instrumental. It also sees the band move away temporarily from the rock wall of sound (Depending on what your idea of “rock” is.).
Anti-Curse:
Julien’s turn, this time with a song which talks about romance. After the bridge is the best section of the song, as we hear full-on guitars with cascading drums.
Letter to an Old Poet:
By this point, I was starting to wonder if there was a democracy in the band as we heard yet another Phoebe trademark song. The track is about surrendering to what you used to be. It also has recycled lyrics from ‘Me & My Dog’, featured on the trio’s 2018 extended play. You can hear a crowd in the background. As the song gently fades, Phoebe closes with a message of hope.
You may think, by reading this, that the album is a fantastic listen. Unfortunately, I have masked that by measuring each track individually. Overall, I felt that for a band dubbed “rock”, there were many downtempo moments and many of the shoegaze side of indie. For me, the term “rock” has not been categorised all that well. There are sub-genres, in fact, many for rock, and this one falls under alternative/indie/shoegaze for me. This was more akin to an album by the XX than full-on rock. I was looking forward to hearing “the Record”, but I had to listen to it twice because my concentration wavered somewhat on the first listen. I felt it was all relatively tame for a “rock” album. There is more energy in a Phoebe Bridgers live performance than this.
Song recommendations: ‘Leonard Cohen’, ‘$20’, ‘Cool About it’
Here is my track-by-track review of her 9th studio album and her second album release of the current year:
Willow:
This isn’t just the opening track of the album, but it is also the leading single. This is Taylor returning to her roots when she was gigging constantly across America to get herself noticed within the industry by basing herself on country music. It’s a bizarre choice as a single, as it hasn’t any of those typical pop traits to chart that high. It is pure country with its delicately plucked acoustic guitar. Her vocal delivery synchronises with the subject of being in love with someone, and you’re trying to make them feel the same way. Taylor expresses this by how we would feel in those moments. From feeling high and excited to feeling low and being unable to breathe from the panic that they don’t love you. There are also some deep lyrics within, so listen carefully.
Champagne Problems:
This piano ballad was written with her boyfriend, who uses the alias William Bowery (Of course, his real name is Joe Alwyn.). Is the subject matter supposed to be about their current relationship? Rather than about a couple in college who share very different views about a night where one wants to break up and the other wants to propose. I don’t know how happy they are, but I can’t see them dropping hints while writing a song together. I also learned that “Champagne Problems” is a phrase (I guess only in America.) that means when an individual’s troubles are genuine but, when put into perspective, are less important than how much others are suffering. Like with “Folklore”, Taylor touches on the very fragile subject of mental health. In this song, the female character mentions her problems with mental health and how the break up of her relationship has further impacted it. I am going to quote some compelling lyrics taken from the male character in this, as he is the one who has been left heartbroken. “Sometimes you just don’t know the answer til someone’s on their knees and asks you; she would have made such a lovely bride, what a shame she’s fucked in the head, they said, but you’ll find the real thing instead”. As you can see, the song is very emotional.
Gold Rush:
Wasn’t this also a song on “Folklore”? I can’t remember, but someone will tell me when they visit my archives this year. Bizarrely, the producer of this track only features once on the record when you consider Jack Antonoff has produced half of her songs over the past three albums. This song is more chart-friendly compared to the previous tracks on the record. This time, the leading character starts falling for someone popular among several others. Unfortunately for the leading female character, the other women chases the man in question. Still, just like the leading female, they are also looking for gold in California, which, when you think about it, makes the title make sense. The leading character becomes jealous and longing to have him, and she decides she can no longer chase him because she has no fight left in her and feels it is futile. Again, some lyrics stood out for me, and they are intense by the lead character. “At dinner parties, I call you out on your contrarian shit, and the coastal town we wandered round had never seen a love as pure as it, and then it fades into the grey of my day-old tea, cause it could never be”.
Tis the Damn Season:
What I found about Taylor’s songwriting is she can tell fables about fictional characters based on actual events or fables about her own life experiences. It is challenging to do the former, as you must design the characters and build the fable around them, but Taylor does this effortlessly. Once again, on this album, she has devised a character from Tupelo, Mississippi, who is leaving her town to achieve her dreams in Hollywood on the big screen. You may be wondering where the Christmas element comes into it. The lead character returns home to enjoy the festivities, where she stumbles across an ex-lover. As one of the lyrics depicts over this electric guitar track, she says how she is breaking her own heart by returning to Los Angeles, where everyone she meets is superficial, including the way she smiles, rather than remaining in Tupelo to get back with her ex-lover and feel loved and happy once more.
Tolerate it:
There appears to be a trend with Taylor and the obsession with the fifth track; the fifth track always seems to be a ballad with a heart-wrenching confession. “Evermore” doesn’t buck the trend. Again, the song is seen from the female perspective. She is sick and tired of devoting her life to her lover, and she is not getting much compassion or any form of emotional connection in return, so she is starting to hate and resent him for that. She has tolerated this behaviour for far too long from him, and now she is ready to confront him. This track perfectly depicts when love fades away from one perspective and turns sour from the other.
No Body, No Crime:
HAIM features on this, but it is based more on the country music scene, from what I recall, rather than the usual rock-based music from HAIM. As you can tell from the title, Taylor, with HAIM doing backing vocals, has gone for a topic about committing a murder. However, it is a double homicide told from different perspectives. The first verse is the narrator’s friend bringing up in a conversation that she thinks her husband is seeing another woman; in the second verse, her friend disappears, and the narrator is sure that the husband killed her and to avenge her friend’s death in the third verse, she kills the husband, but by doing this she compromises the case. Again, this is another powerful fable told by Taylor on this record.
Happiness:
The calibre of this song is quite astonishing when you consider it was the last one to be written in just under a week before the album was due to be released. Most might panic and therefore not put much effort into the last song they are writing just in case they miss the deadline by taking too long, but Taylor has managed to create a good song under that pressure and have it all done and ready to be included on the album. The story is both one of despair and optimism. The individual is going through the agony and six degrees of separation phase of splitting up with their lover, but they show signs of optimism, knowing that happiness will return once this phase has passed. The production complements the lyrics with its slow tempo and melancholic tone. Is the individual Taylor? It shows a mature approach to handling a breakup compared to her as a teenager, where she attacked every ex with venom over wax. If the character is indeed Taylor, then she has shown that as she has got older, she can move on and enjoy the next one to enter her life.
Dorothea:
Remember the track “Tis the Damn Season” earlier on and the unknown female? Well, this is her name and the continuation of the story. However, this is not told from Dorothea’s perspective but by her ex-lover. He was devastated when she moved to Hollywood and longed to be with her. He also ponders, now she is in L.A. chasing her dreams, whether she pauses to think about him. Although the subject is deep and emotional, the song has a relatively upbeat tempo.
Coney Island:
Now, I expected HAIM to feature, but the National? I wasn’t expecting that. Nor was I expecting a duet between Taylor Swift and Matt Berninger. However, I discovered that the National’s Aaron Dressner produces most of the tracks on this album, so it makes sense for Taylor to collaborate either by request or suggested by Aaron. The subject matter is once again that of broken love. This time, it is about a couple reminiscing on the relationship and how it fell apart because the levels of commitment were not balanced. The song also appears to be the couple trying to work out what went wrong and trying to see if they can try again. Taylor’s melodic vocals complement Matt’s customary raspy yet deep vocals.
Ivy:
The banjo is the main instrument this time. It features the first of two collaborations with Justin Vernon of Bon Iver (Later on, the entire band feature.) over a story about a wife committing adultery and subsequently falling in love with her secret lover. Even though she continues the affair as she enjoys the attention, she is trying to stay faithful simultaneously. It is similar to the story in “illicit Affairs” from the previous album and is also freakishly the tenth track.
Cowboy Like Me:
Another song inspired by her roots in country, the story is that of gold diggers who, instead of chasing those with wealth, end up falling for each other. Marcus Mumford from Mumford and Sons provides backing vocals. The song is also typical of a song likely to be composed by Mumford and Sons with guitars, mandolins, harmonicas, and anything from country music you can think of.
Long Story Short:
From an album steeped in country, this track departs from that with its catchy pop chorus, drums, and guitars out of indie rock. You can see this being on her albums before her current two. Taylor goes after the media and the misogynists who tried to ruin her career a couple of years ago (See my first review on the album where she goes fucking ballistic on those people for the whole story.). However, rather than getting herself worked up, Taylor’s vocals are balanced and calm. Even the lyrics are about not sweating the small stuff. She displays happiness knowing she is content in her relationship and that she is way past all this petty bullshit from her enemies. She writes lyrics to her past self to let these things slide and let her enemies defeat themselves by being starved of her attention and reaction. Taylor has shown a lot of maturity so far on the record.
Marjorie:
I am starting to wonder if “Evermore” is the continuation of “Folklore” with the topics, sound, and production. It seems like it is. Still, it doesn’t bother me a jot because I prefer Taylor when writing music in the genre her heart belongs to. Pop was to get a wider audience, but country is where her heart is. Also, there is another reason this is a continuation, and it is related to the thirteenth track of the respective albums. “Folklore” was an ode to her grandfather, who fought in World War II, and “Evermore” focuses on her grandmother, Marjorie Finlay, an opera singer whom Taylor didn’t appreciate until she passed away when Taylor was just a teenager. Taylor regrets this and wishes she could go back and fix this with her grandmother. It is also a grand, haunting gesture, that Taylor used her late grandmother’s vocals for the backing track. Sends chills down your spine.
Closure:
Many of us can relate to the topic here. I’m sure we have all been in a relationship where it ended badly, and we wanted to explain ourselves later on after the dust had settled as to why, but our ex simply refuses the closure and doesn’t want to know. This song describes that. In this case, it’s a male looking for closure from the female, but she has moved on and doesn’t find it necessary to explain it, rather than doing something to avenge the hurt he caused. The lyrics mention that he wants to remain friends after the closure and that he’s angry she won’t hear him out.
Evermore:
The closing and my favourite track. Sorry, but it’s got Bon Iver on it. What more is there to say? Justin Vernon and the rest of the band produce good music. I love this piano-based song with Taylor and Justin doing a cypher and harmonising together, which touches on depression with a mix of dark and optimism to end the album. The highlight is the cypher for me; it is scarce to see vocalists go bar-for-bar like they were rapping or sharing a poem.
Song recommendations: “Evermore”, “Coney Island”, “Long Story Short”.
We start the record with a typical Shania Twain track that fits into her 1990s sound with a short guitar riff. Still, rather than the guitars playing throughout the song like they would have done back then, they gradually fade before you can hear what sounds like steel drums taking centre stage and taking us somewhere else that we would never expect Shania to take us with. I’ve never listened to a Shania Twain track so far removed from the country as this. It’s like a country and calypso-infused sound.
Home Now:
Ah, now we are back to the typical Shania Twain sound as her country roots come to the fore with this track that features banjos, fiddles and guitars. A song that you would hear in Nashville bars.
Light of My Life:
As you can guess from the title, this track is about romance and is sung by Shania in narrating mode rather than a personal experience of hers (Who knows? Maybe it is her own experience.), where she takes on the role of a secret admirer expressing their feelings to a crush who is blissfully unaware. You could say that the song is a bit like the Police’s “Every Breath You Take” as it is rather sinister and unsettling that the secret admirer will reject all other offers in the hope of getting with the crush who has no idea of their existence. The song is wrapped around drum loops and the melancholic chords associated with songs such as this (Or, in the case of this track, just the one in Em.). The chorus, though, sees Shania deliver a fantastic hook that has been absent for twenty years in her songs of late.
Poor Me:
This song is very personal, and Shania proceeds to tell the story of her divorce that happened almost ten years ago and how her heart took ages to sew back together (Naturally). There are some powerful lyrics in this one, and it even mentions that she caught him out lying and how he could leave Shania for another woman. In the short chorus, she seems to be forgetting about all the pain and asking the listener, who must be the person behind the bar hearing this story, to pour her another. So, yeah. This song is seen from the perspective of Shania drowning her sorrows and pouring her heart out to the person behind the bar who keeps filling up her glass when she requests.
Who’s Gonna Be Your Girl:
I loved the background vocals in this sappy love song that opened with tremolo guitar and built up nicely into the very harmonious chorus.
More Fun:
Another track that showed Shania’s versatility as an artist. This track would look good on Broadway and in London’s West End with thumping piano and Cabaret sound throughout. I can’t imagine it ever being a single because of this, but it does work, and who cares what those who dictate their record collection by what’s in the mainstream charts think, anyway.
I’m Alright:
It looks like a follow-up to “Poor Me” as Shania foretells what unravelled after the divorce and breakup with her ex-husband while a soft acoustic guitar accompanies a thumping drum beat. The actual moment of the song, though, is when the sound of thundering hand claps meets the chorus, which she does acapella, as you would hear at a gospel church service.
Let’s Kiss and Make up:
Well, another song that showcases her will to experiment as we now hear a track with a reggae and calypso sound that makes you feel that you are on a Barbadian beach until you are greeted by the guys you hear on the Doritos advert in the shape of Mexican band, the Mariachis as you can listen to all the horns ring out in the chorus.
Where Do You Think You’re Going:
This track could easily feature as part of an official soundtrack with its angelic chorus and the fact it is a piano ballad with sublime vocals by Shania.
Roll Me on the River:
Wow. Taken by surprise with this song. Don’t forget that Shania is originally a country artist, but this song should have Ladysmith Black Mambazo with its sounds of Africa.
We Got Something They Don’t:
A track very much harking back to a vintage Shania love song. You have thumping percussion, a smooth bass line and many horns. I also noticed a very Michael Jackson-esque harmony on the outro, and you have to wonder, is Shania paying some homage to Michael?
Because of You:
Yes, it is named after a Kelly Clarkson song, but no, it is not in the same vein. Instead, Shania has gone for a sentimental love song with this. It is dedicated to her current lover and sees her finally recovering from the heartache of a failed marriage. She mentions in the lyrics, “Because of you, I’m me”. This suggests that she has finally rediscovered herself through her new flame after all that happened. The song is completed with soft acoustic guitar playing, and I imagine that the drummer used brushed drumsticks, as the drums are soft, too.
You Can’t Buy Love:
A song about how to deal with and overcome all those tricky situations we all incur at some point along our road in life. It features hand claps, several harmonies and a jolly chord progression that envelopes itself in the primary melody.
Life’s About to Get Good:
As you can see from the title, the premise is that Shania is walking away from her past and heading towards the here and now. This track was released to tease the album, and I can see why that was. This song is not only uplifting and full of optimism but is undoubtedly ready for the arena when she heads out on tour with its anthemic country hooks accompanied by a rather unusual taste of electronica pop. Looking at my research, I also discovered this song scored her a first top 40 billboard chart hit in well over a decade. Did Shania have a premonition when she wrote and recorded this track?
Soldier:
Ah, another song that has a familiar theme across the pond. A loved one expressing how much they miss the soldier who has been away on a tour of some war-torn country for longer than the narrator here finds necessary (Is any war needed? In my own opinion, they are all fucking bollocks created by idiots who want to steal another country’s oil. Too much? I don’t fucking care. That should be accurate for those who are wide awake. Anyway, back to the song and off politics (How ironic. The song is political, anyway.), this heavily keyed piano ballad and Shania’s emotional and soaring vocals completed with strings could well be used as a track for a film about the subject or maybe even a drama on HBO? It’s a highly emotional song and does more than justice on the subject.
All in All:
The title suggests that this track summarises all the feelings she has laid bare on the record. Indeed, it is her reminiscing and looking forward to all the good and bad times she will cross along her path. This coming-of-age track features a nice guitar riff with an eighties feel. I was surprised that the record ended in a mid-tempo vain when I was expecting a very soft piano ballad.
Overall: Fucking hell. We discovered an awful lot about the trials and tribulations of Shania on this record. I will not lie that some of the tracks affected me (So what? I get emotional. I write poetry, so I can relate.). The lyrics were both uplifting, emotional, melancholic and eye-opening. Especially “Poor Me”, where it’s all aired about how she felt
during her divorce and the events that lead up to it. I was surprised to hear Shania deviate from country and rock to venture into reggae, calypso, gospel, rnb and electronica. Not to mention the sounds inspired by Africa where it would have been wholly appropriate to feature Ladysmith Black Mambazo, Labi Siffre, Baaba Maal, I could go on and on (Yes, I know my African musicians and bands. Surprised? Don’t be. I have a very eclectic taste.). It certainly was a departure from what we all became accustomed to during the early years of her time in the music industry. Some tracks could feature in films or the type of dramas you see on HBO. Now, that does show her diversity. She should have ended the record with a light piano ballad, which would have been perfect. As we know, the final track is titled “All in All”, so when we summarise events that have happened, we tend to talk about them calmly and soothingly rather than raising our voices in anger. That would have made for a better ending. All in All (Excuse the pun.) Shania is back and more than capable of producing another brilliant album when she is ready to return to the studio. A side note from this, Richard Ashcroft was on Twitter talking about how Liam Gallagher’s debut album was number one. I corrected him and said that was currently Shania Twain’s record, to which he replied, “That don’t Impress Me Much”. 9/10
Honest Opinions 