Week 17: Fontaines D.C.- Skinty Fia

As you might recall, I wrote a review of their second album, “A Hero’s Death”, by accident. As you know, I write a review for the number one album each week or whenever a new one is on the top spot. Well, this particular week back in 2020, the Irish band were on course for the top spot, but the previous number one held them off. However, I wrote a review on “A Hero’s Death” because it was more or less certain on the back of this information. I listened to the record, wrote my review a day later, and uploaded it the following day. It’s nice to know I will not need to do a bit of background to introduce you to the lads from Dublin. I will, though, do something I have yet to do so far.

As you know, I have done track-by-track reviews, summary track-by-track reviews, and plain old, elongated reviews. I will do essential track reviews on the tracks I enjoyed this time. The album consists of ten tracks. I will write a review, long or short, on the highlights of “Skinty Fia”:

In ár gCroíthe go deo: 

This track opens the album and translates as “In Our Hearts Forever”. It’s nice to see some Gaeilge used by a band, particularly from Ireland. It has been a while since I’ve seen Gaeilge used by Irish bands, unless it is Clannad or the like. This song is steeped in Irish history—the song protests against the English who invaded Ireland 800 or more years ago. The band’s instrumentalists provide backing vocals, repeating the track title repeatedly as Grian enters over a glum and sinister bassline. The song is based on the event of Maggie Keane, who wanted a Celtic cross with the track name inscribed on the headstone. However, the occupying British Army brought the Church of England over, which denied Maggie’s request. Their reason is that the message was written in the native language, which would lead to political connotations. Despite this, the Irish courts ruled in favour of Maggie’s family. The band felt the song epitomises how the natives still need to fight for their identity. From the outset, the band have decided to go political. If that makes some of you uncomfortable because they want to talk about the occupation of Ireland, then stop reading this review and give the album a miss. 


Big Shot:


As you may well know, the Dubliners have moved across the sea to London, and this song reflects that. Whereas Dublin still has opportunities to expand, the band’s move to London has opened up more avenues than were on offer back in their native Dublin. The band can pursue their dream of being the best by moving across the sea. For example, look at some of these lyrics: “I travelled to Space”, found the moon too small, and home is a pin, rusting through a map, I go there to pray, do my resting at mass”. What Grian is saying, from what I can decipher, is that they have travelled around Ireland, but it isn’t enough to achieve their dream. Despite being a big city, Dublin is nothing compared to the other cities they have played in worldwide. They only return to Dublin when there is a break during touring (Or the tour has ended.) and attend mass. The last line, I believe to be they only have time to reflect and relax away from music when they go to mass (I am also Catholic like the lads, and you feel far from relaxed at mass. It feels like you are in the dock listening to a judge telling you how guilty you are.)


Jackie Down the Line: 


Another political track. I will explain why briefly, but this song is the opposite of ‘Big Shot’. The band talks about why they are proud to be from Dublin (In the title sense, at least.). The song has an Indie 90s feel to it. “Jackie” is a variation of “Jackeen”. This is a derogatory term used by people outwith of Dublin. A Jackeen is someone who has become an “Irish Brit”. They have embraced the British culture and have become flag-wavers of the Union Jack. I first heard this track on the Late Late Show with Jimmy Fallon. It featured a steady drumbeat, acoustic guitar, and a reverb effect on Conor Curley’s electric guitar—a method used by his counterpart Edge from U2. The song talks about a woman named Sally, a toxic male killed. I haven’t looked into the case, but it highlights that there is still this problem of men attacking women in Ireland. Indeed, Grian’s vocals are melancholic. You can hear his soul slide away during the verses as he foretells the fable.


I Love You: 


So far, I haven’t heard anything like the punk-infused songs I had heard on their previous albums, and this track was no different. This time, the band took influences from Joy Division, New Order, and the Cure. It reminded me of a darker version of ‘Blue Monday’. Why? It wasn’t quite a dance track but had that Peter Hook bassline. I am sure I have seen Deego sporting a t-shirt of all the bands before now. So, it is no surprise he has added Peter Hook and Simon Gallup basslines. The subject revolves around the Irish youth, how they are shackled by capitalism and religion, how the lockdown has affected their well-being and the sinking feeling of what the future holds. At the same time, while trapped in this current situation. Grian’s delivery is spot-on for the subject. He delivers the vocals with ferocious anger as he addresses the issues and describes how he felt growing up in that situation.


Bloomsday: 


It leads off from ‘I Love You’ because it, too, is dark. This time, however, it goes even more profound and sinister. Again, over this gloomy instrumentation, Grian’s delivery is perfect. His lyrics sound like a man talking with a soft and melancholic tone. Again, Grian highlights the lack of hope for the youth in Ireland, particularly in his native Dublin.


Skinty Fia:


 As you can tell by the name, this is the title track. Does it move away from the previous two songs about Dublin? The answer is no. The song can be described as darkwave over a low bassline as Grian talks about Dublin’s shortcomings.


Roman Holiday: 


Unlike, let’s call it the Doomed Dublin trilogy, this song is more upbeat and has a message of hope. Once again, the guitar effect Edge uses is utilised by Curley over a stark bassline and fragmented percussion. The song is quite apt with the current war in Eastern Europe. It is about a couple moving to Dublin who can be welcomed and make it their home, which Ukrainian refugees have been doing in Dublin and all over Europe. Even though you are not from Ireland, you can still embrace it and have an Irish heart. I first heard this at Alexandra Palace on the current tour.


the Couple Across the Way: 


In one of the quieter moments on the record, Grian sings alone, accompanied by an accordion and piano. Grian tells the story of looking out of his window and narrating a typical day in the life of his neighbours adjacent. He has never spoken to them to find out their names or interests. He observes them argue, make up, and repeat the cycle daily. He opts to assume the role of one half of the couple as the song nears the end and the story becomes more straightforward.


Nabokov: 

The album closer has a Verve air about it. Like the Verve, the track is melancholic, but Fontaines DC adds a fast tempo, whereas the Verve would opt for a plodding one. For those of you who are learned readers, you would have probably detected the song title is by a novelist, and just like in one of Nabokov’s books, the character in the track depicts that of Lolita—a lady who no longer feels optimistic and is fed up with being downtrodden. The only way out of the situation to end the pain is to take her own life. That sentiment is expressed in the lyrics “I did you a favour, I bled myself dry, ” as Grian delivers it, seemingly depicting the character screaming angrily. Some might say it is a dark and sinister way to close out, but the band have never been one to abide by the laws. They have always gone against the grain and diced with danger, which has worked since they started playing. Unlike “Dogrel” and “A Hero’s Death”, “Skinty Fia” has been sobering to listen to, and the subjects on offer invoke all the emotions we feel. The record also goes deep into our imaginations.


Song recommendations: ‘Jackie Down the Line’, ‘the Couple Across the Way’, ‘Roman Holiday’


9/10

Week Thirty-Two: Fontaines D.C.- A Hero’s Death

I remember hearing about the buzz of this band from Dublin a few years back from some folks I follow from Scotland on Twitter, so I first assumed they were an up-and-coming band from Glasgow or Edinburgh. Imagine my surprise when I finally listened to one of the many videos shared on that platform via YouTube. The track, funnily enough, was also the title of their debut album “Dogrel”. I have to say, I loved the energy, but the lyrics were…beyond basic. Their lead vocalist, unfortunately, didn’t impress me much, and I wondered what was the point of having Grian Chatten in the first place. His vocals sounded like a drunk punter slurring through a song on the karaoke machine. Despite that, his flat vocals work pretty well in the punk genre. Let’s face it: Johnny Rotten was hardly blessed with amazing vocal ability. I can’t think of many punk vocalists who can sing. Billie Joe Armstrong, maybe? After hearing the title track, I gave their debut album a full listen and was impressed with the picture they painted of their beloved Dublin City. I found the album had more structure lyrically than just that one song. Even if you’ve never been to Dublin or Mother Ireland, you have a good idea of what life is like from “Dogrel”. As much as I have never found the lyrical content impressive, I appreciate the energy the music provides; it is a bit like IDLES. There are minimal lyrics but fantastic energy in the instrumentation.

That’s enough brief history on the band and their debut; let’s review their second and latest album, funnily enough, also named after the track “A Hero’s Death”. They didn’t bother relying on the success of “Dogrel”; as you can imagine, they decided to intentionally head into another direction with the whole instrumentation and lyrical content. After all, writing about living in Dublin becomes quite challenging when you last visited before being on the road to promote your previous work. Grian has said that the band would have felt like they were frauds talking about life in Dublin again, as they haven’t been there much to experience it the past year, and therefore, it wouldn’t be fair on the listener to buy an album, which didn’t represent anything

authentic, thus making the listener lose interest in the band.

Instead, the band has talked about the places they have been on the road and what they have experienced and seen. As you can imagine, life on the road isn’t always sweet when you’re constantly sharing space on a tour bus, and this album certainly shows that as it discusses their excessive drinking, loneliness, depression, and fighting with each other because you are sick of the sight of each other during a long and arduous tour. I recommend a good documentary on life on the road and how this is depicted perfectly. It’s about Keane, so go and look online or buy their DVD. This album is more downbeat and lacks the energy of “Dogrel”, but I suppose that would always be the premise to replicate their mood on tour. For example, “Living in America” is very slow and melancholic. Then the tempo is switched up on “A Televised Mind.” the latter is not great lyrically, but you can feel the energy from the rhythmic pulsing of the guitar and the thumping bass of the drum. Once again, the title track is minimal with its lyrics (I believe, from what I remember hearing, it just repeats “Life isn’t always empty” for the duration?), but the instrumentation does it justice.

The band does not apologise for their change in direction and even know they may lose fans by not keeping in line with the debut. They even acknowledge that some people will be disappointed with the second record, but unfortunately, life has changed, and this is who they now are, so they cannot write songs about living in Dublin anymore. In fact, “A Televised Mind” is a dig at those who want to be appeased. “A Televised Mind” seems to be about people stuck in their ways and refusing to accept change. It is like some Oasis fans who can’t take that Noel does the music he wants to do.

Dan Carey’s services proved very successful on “Dogrel”, so the band chose him again. This time, as mentioned in this review, the sound would be very different in line with the band’s fresh outlook. The first record was very compact, but Dan gives more of the spotlight on the music this time, so you can fully appreciate Carlos O’Connell and Conor Curley on the guitars and Tom Coll on the drums. There is also room for ballads like “Sunny” with a gothic-like sound.

It is also worth noting to get the sound they wanted, and they were listening to quite a lot of the Beach Boys while they were touring stateside. The band wanted to make a record that wasn’t straight down the line, and that the Beach Boys heavily inspired “A Hero’s Death”.

As much as I liked the record, I am once again left unimpressed with the elementary lyrics that anyone could make up on the spot and the flatness of Grian’s vocals. Now, he is quite passionate about his profession, but it doesn’t come through in his studio performances and onstage performances. It’s quite sad. The music has the energy, albeit at times on this record brings it down, but Grian remains at the same tempo throughout. It is good that the band is willing to experiment so early in their career, but they are in danger of losing their identity, which accrued them fans. They must maintain sight of what made them unique, or they will fall into the generic bands they are frequently associated with.

Song recommendations: “Sunny”, “No”, “A Televised Mind”.

7/10