No need for an introduction, as I already did “CALM”, the album named after all the members’ first names. So, onto 5 Seconds of Summer’s sixth studio record, “Everyone’s a Star!”. This effort features pop-rock, electronica, and electro-punk over reflective lyrics. The album screams confidence with its identity. It may be modern, but it still has the emotional element of the band and their melodic instincts. Now, I listened to the “Full Evolved” version, which is the equivalent of a deluxe edition, featuring songs centred around specific members and therefore giving it an even more personal listen.

As you know, I reviewed ‘CALM” and this album feels like a combination between that and “5SOS5”. Why? because “CALM” had atmospheric experimentation, and “5SOS5” was more crispy pop. The production features tight percussion, clean vocal layering, synth-heavy soundscapes, and is wrapped in personal subjects such as burnout, insomnia, self-image, and vulnerability.

The emotional element is what makes the record strong. Although there are upbeat tracks, they still have undertones of reflection. The likes of The Smiths and Oasis are known for putting melancholic lyricism over upbeat instrumentation, so they have adopted this approach.

Let us have a look at the standout tracks and give them a kind of track-by-track review. I will also include my standouts from the “Fully Evolved” section, but not explain why. I will leave it up to you to figure out:

NOT OK:

The key track that blends vulnerability with a cinematic hook. The listener will resonate with the theme, as the lyrics express… well. The title says it all.

Boyband:

The lads take a comedic approach to being labelled a boy band since they first burst onto the scene with pop-punk, which is a welcome break from the melancholy on the album.

Telephone Busy:

One of my complaints, which I will highlight in due course, is how short the tracks are, and this is a case in point. A pop track aimed at TikTok viewers, who, let us face it, have a short attention span. A polished earmworm track to say the least.

I’m Scared I’ll Never Sleep Again:

A track addressing the band’s struggle with insomnia, and a slower pace to the majority of the rest of the record. This vulnerable, atmospheric track features a sublime arrangement over emotionally powerful lyrics that will move the listener.

The Rocks:

Gritty and raw, and a great way to end the album. A quintessential 5SOS track.

“Fully Evolved” highlights: ’Start Over’, ‘Wishful Dreaming’, ‘Cool Dad’:

The “Fully Evolved” edition is the most intimate . The tracks, as I mentioned earlier, are specific to each member and therefore more personal, and sound less polished than the majority of the tracks, which, in my opinion, works as a healthy balance. It is also great to see each member tell their own personal stories.

Now, onto something else I mentioned before, and that is how short the tracks are:

Yes, I am impressed by how the themes all tie into the album, but the shortness of the tracks is an obvious drawback.

The standard edition is just over 36 minutes, whereas the “Fully Evolved” edition weighs in at just over 49 minutes, making the listening time that little bit longer. However, most of the tracks are just finding their feet before they come to an end. Bridges, and outros are too short, and some of the songs never reach their entire journeys. This could be achieved by adding more verses or extending the bridges.

Yeah, it does not ruin the listening experience, but on certain tracks, they could have been extended to enhance it. “Fully Evolved” compensates for the brief listen of the standard edition, so I would recommend opting for the “Fully Evolved” edition.

So, my recommendation for ‘Everyone’s a Star!” is the “Fully Evolved” edition. It is emotionally honest, polished, and fits into their wall-of-sound aesthetic. The standard edition is a mixture of pop and vulnerability, and the “Fully Evolved” edition tracks are far from filler, as they take you on a genuinely personal journey of each member.

And once again, let us talk about where the record falls down. The shortness of the tracks. You want to hear more lyricism or instrumentation before they reach their conclusion. The tracks deserve more space to breathe over the quality on display.

The album as a whole is tightly produced, thought-provoking, with melancholic lyrics over upbeat instrumentation, and bonus tracks that act as more than filler,which some records tend to fall foul of.

Song recommendations: ‘Cool as Dad’, ‘NOT OK’, ‘The Rocks’

8/10