I confess, I approached Lady Gaga’s new album, “Mayhem,” with a certain level of anticipation. After my positive review of “Chromatica,” where I praised her embrace of classic house music, I was eager to see where she would take her sound next. Unfortunately, “Mayhem” proved to be a significant disappointment, transporting me back to a sound I frankly, never enjoyed.

Despite the intriguing black-and-white cover depicting Lady Gaga in a gothic, almost brooding light, the music within feels like a deliberate throwback to her late-2000s era. Think ‘Poker Face’ and ‘Bad Romance’, the very songs that cemented her pop superstardom. For me, that’s where the problem lies. While those tracks clearly resonated with millions, they never clicked with me.

“Mayhem,” in my opinion, echoes that same formula. The heavy synths, repetitive hooks, and hyper-theatrical vocals that defined that early period are all present and accounted for. Instead of forging new sonic territory, “Mayhem” feels like a nostalgic revisit, a move that feels out of step with the progression promised by “Chromatica”.

Frankly, I couldn’t manage to glean any enjoyment from the listening experience. The songs, to my ears, felt derivative and lacked the innovative spark that I’d come to expect from Lady Gaga. For this reason, I’m refraining from assigning a rating or recommending any specific tracks.

The most enjoyable part of listening to “Mayhem” was undoubtedly when it was over. Perhaps fans who adore Gaga’s early work will find something to appreciate in this return to her roots. However, for those hoping for continued evolution and sonic exploration, “Mayhem” might just leave you feeling… well, let’s just say underwhelmed.